Most Popular
-
Kill Gus Boulis's Killer?
Paul Brandreth didn't want to murder anybody. Or did he?
-
City Hall Stinks
There's a war on Dinner Key, and Marc Sarnoff is a bomb-thrower.
-
Mayor of the Nude Beach
So he's naked and in his seventies. He's still the coolest guy you'll ever meet.
-
I Have HIV
But I'm not telling you, babe. Happy Valentine's Day!
-
Vamos a Cuba!
Join us as we try to hitch a ride to the island before the gold rush strikes.
-
City Hall Stinks (58)
There's a war on Dinner Key, and Marc Sarnoff is a bomb-thrower.
-
Sarnoff Turns His Back on Blacks (20)
Coconut Grove's other half feels left out.
-
Sarnoff Shmarnoff (14)
Commissioner Marc's claim to a famous bloodline just might be fiction.
-
Jumping the Snapper (5)
Brosia boards the Mediterranean bandwagon, with mixed results.
-
The Reporter and the Tranny (4)
He kissed her, um, him, and that was only the beginning.
-
Kill Gus Boulis's Killer?
Paul Brandreth didn't want to murder anybody. Or did he?
-
City Hall Stinks
There's a war on Dinner Key, and Marc Sarnoff is a bomb-thrower.
-
Mayor of the Nude Beach
So he's naked and in his seventies. He's still the coolest guy you'll ever meet.
-
I Have HIV
But I'm not telling you, babe. Happy Valentine's Day!
-
Vamos a Cuba!
Join us as we try to hitch a ride to the island before the gold rush strikes.
-
Spitzer and the Hookers, Part Two
04:30PM 03/11/08 -
The Party Crasher - Rick Ross Trilla Release Party at Mansion
08:51AM 03/11/08 -
Magic City Kitty -- Patience, a Virtue and a Curse?
08:42AM 03/11/08 -
Rick Ross "Speedin" With a New Album
02:53PM 03/11/08 -
Tuesday Afternoon Music Fix: Del the Funky Homosapien, Cajun Dance Party and more
11:39AM 03/11/08 -
R.E.M. Disappoints at Langerado
08:49PM 03/10/08
What we are writing about
- Art Basel
- Arturo Sandoval Jazz Club
- Carnival Center
- Coconut Grove
- Coral Gables
- downtown Miami
- Fillmore Miami Beach
- Fort Lauderdale
- Francisco Goya
- Freedom Tower
- Hugo Chávez
- In the Continuum
- John Timoney
- Julia Tuttle Causeway
- Karen Kilimnik
- Marc Sarnoff
- Miami-Dade County Library
- Miami-Dade County...
- Miami Beach
- Miami local art
- Miami local music
- Miami local theater
- Museum of Contemporary...
- Patrick Williams
- sex offenders
- South Beach
- South Miami
- Studio A
- Wii
- Xbox
Recent Articles By Rob Jordan
-
If You Build It
They won’t come ... or at least not without better planning
-
Artist as Prisoner
Ed Bobb punched a few keys and went to jail. Where's the justice?
-
Booted
These folks want to stay, but soon they'll have no choice
-
Orchid Jungle
One man's search to restore rare blossoms to their historic Florida home
-
While You Were Out
Florida's educational system leaves a lot to be desired.
National Features
-
Houston Press
"It Was Like an Armageddon Movie"
For days after Hurricane Rita, a Texas prison was hell on earth.
By Chris Vogel -
SF Weekly
The Candidate
Our columnist knows Ralph Nader's running mate all too well.
By Matt Smith -
The Pitch
How Not To Be a Rap Star
First of all, lay off the Ecstasy.
By Nadia Pflaum -
Village Voice
Project Runaway
What becomes a gossip columnist most?
By Michael Musto
Commie Book Ban
Vamos a Cuba has become an unlikely political lightning rod
By Rob Jordan
Published: August 10, 2006On a recent Tuesday evening, as traffic cut through steady rain on SW Seventh Street, about two dozen graying Cuban émigrés gathered in a nondescript room near the airport to plot a new crusade in their eternal war against the ailing Fidel Castro.
Their plan to pull a children's book called Vamos a Cuba from school library shelves across Miami-Dade County had already attracted national media attention and provoked protests in Cuba. A legal challenge by the American Civil Liberties Union had sparked rumors of a showdown in the nation's highest court. Which was why leaders of the old guard exile community had called this meeting: to ensure a united front at the press conference scheduled for the next morning.
The press conference to be held at the Versailles restaurant in Little Havana would be a carefully managed, media-friendly event. This private strategy session, convened at the tiny headquarters of La Junta Patriotica Cubana, was a more freeform affair. Yes, they were here to discuss the book in question, a vile piece of propaganda. But there were other issues to talk about first.
"Angelina Jolie has a tattoo of Che Guevara ... like Mike Tyson," said Emilio Izquierdo as he shook his head in mild bewilderment.
Izquierdo, a former political prisoner whose inexhaustible hatred for Fidel compelled him to protest the 2001 Latin Grammys, at which Cuban musicians performed, went on: "We're in a war of great magnitude. The United States is changing. We have to take off our shoes at the airport. There are attempted acts of violence against our public transportation." Cubans are under threat, too, he said, stabbing his meaty fingers at the air. "Extreme people on the left, they don't like us because we don't like socialism. People in the extreme right, they don't like us because we don't live in Liberty City, because we created our own economy. We are the only minority that people can say horrible things against."
On this point everyone could agree the old-timers squeezed into guayaberas, the Bay of Pigs veterans, the politicians, and the enraged ex-kindergarten teachers alike. Miami's Cuban exiles were being overlooked, insulted, persecuted. Once again, they were being forced to rally in their own defense.
Their oppressor is a 32-page book from the Vamos series, which had been in Miami-Dade public school libraries for five years before anyone complained. During that time, no one had questioned why Vamos a Colombia fails to mention decades of kidnappings by leftist guerrillas or why Vamos a China omits any mention of the millions who starved during Mao's Great Leap Forward. But after one parent's initial complaint, critics of Vamos a Cuba came out of the woodwork. The book's reference to July 26 as a dance-happy "carnaval" was off-base, critics said, because under Castro, the day had become little more than a joyless, speech-filled commemoration of the revolution. Rock paintings described in the book as 1000 years old actually dated to the Sixties. And as for chicken and rice being the favorite dish in Cuba: How are you going to eat chicken and rice if there's a shortage of both?
Izquierdo, one of several who had called for the meeting, sat at the impromptu dais, a plastic folding table. He was surrounded by a gallery of other exile luminaries, all of them eager to bask in the sudden spotlight of the Vamos a Cuba controversy. Miami-Dade school board member and state Senate candidate Frank Bolaños nodded his head occasionally. Activist Ana Margarita, known for having mistakenly married a man later revealed to be a Cuban spy, smiled wanly. Servilo Pérez, a political prisoner for more than twenty years in Cuba, held his head in his hand as he listened. Later they would be joined by Julio Cabarga, a major figure in exile politics since the Seventies and president of the Junta, a group dedicated, in the words of its manifesto, "to the noble endeavor of liberating one of the last holdings of Soviet and Communist imperialism."
As Izquierdo rambled on, cell phones in the audience occasionally broke into frantic Latin dance rhythms, echoing off the room's gray tile floor. Two young girls, daughters of school board candidate Manny Anon, squirmed in the front row until Anon gave them the okay to go outside.
Finally Izquierdo got to the point. He held up the now-infamous cover photo of Vamos a Cuba. It showed a group of smiling children dressed in blue-and-white school uniforms, which also serve as uniforms for the Pioneers, Cuba's Communist youth group.
"I don't want to see a photo like this," he said. "It makes my stomach sick."
Juan Amador was also on hand that night. A boyish-looking 36-year-old lunch truck entrepreneur, Amador had given rise to the Vamos a Cuba controversy this past spring, after his nine-year-old daughter, a third-grader at Marjory Stoneman Douglas Elementary School, brought home a copy of the book. The simplistic travel book, also published in English, is part of a series meant to introduce kindergarten through second-grade students to life in various countries.
Amador, a former political prisoner in Cuba, saw the book's cover as flagrant propaganda for the Castro regime. Among other passages, Amador pointed to a sentence in the book "People in Cuba eat, work, and go to school like you do" as a particularly egregious denial of the political indoctrination, food rationing, and repression that pervade Cuban life.
"I don't want to teach my daughter all the cruel realities of Cuba, but I don't want to lie either," he said recently.











I am a former Miami Dade Schools teacher and am glad to be out of that horrific school system. I am not surprised to hear that Vamos a Cuba has been removed from the school libraries. Academic freedom in Miami Dade schools has been an issue for many years. I recall having to get permission to use videos for instructional use because of content. Also, a Cuban administrator from the exile community became irate when I wanted my students to read an article with a pie graph illustrating varying views in the community over Elian Gonzalez. Based on my experiences with Cuban school administrators from the exile community, their views were narrow and viewpoints beyond their perspective were not open for discussion.
I think books such as Vamos a Cuba have instructional value because teachers can encourage critical literacy from controversial books that have been challenged because we have to go beyond our comfort zone. As a teacher for the Department of Defense Schools in Germany, I plan to use Vamos a Cuba with gifted students. They will have to do research and discover why this book has been challenged in Miami. This sounds like a teachable moment too good to pass up! I will prepare a podcast for former colleages in Miami to access when this project is published.
The book, The Kite Runner by Khalid Hosseini is being challenged by parents in DoDDs schools in Germany because the setting is war torn Afghanistan. Issues include politics, violence, brutality homosexuality from a different perspective that requires us to go out of our confort zone in order to open our minds and learn more about Afghanistan because that is where we are fighting the war on terrorism.
I just returned from N. Cyprus where there is still animosity between Turkish and Greek Cypriots. By visiting a museum in N. Nicosia (Lefkosa), I viewed photographs showing Greek atrocities. To me, this was an opportunity to recognise propoganda and one sidedness and discuss with my high school aged son. He studies philosophy in in private European school and is open minided enough to see varied solutions to one problem.
It sounds like narrow minded people from the Cuban exile community need to get over their hardhips they experienced and realize that when Castro came to power, they had new opportunities in the US and shouldappreciate a market place of ideas even if some of them are out of their comfort zone. They need to be reminded of the First Amendment and that the US is diverse--there are other views besides those who live in Miami. Vamaos a Cuba sounds like a teachable moment that can encourage dialogue from a variety of perspectives.
I hope that the Vamos a Cuba will be back on the shelves in Miami-Dade schools and discussed in classrooms in order to open people's minds and help students recognize for themselves the alleged inaccuracies and propaganda by arguing with the printed word and pictures iin the book.
Comment by Betty Roberts — August 19, 2007 @ 03:43PM