Attorneys, physicians, advocacy groups, union members, community activists, and local politicians all expressed opposition to expanding the county's jail footprint.
"Just as a pointed gun to the face is a threat, this jail indicates the desire to put someone in chains, and it is also a threat to this community," said Jahdiel Murray, a Miami Gardens youth advocate with MG Families Unite. "Who do you plan to jail, black and brown bodies again?"
Opposing the construction of another jail, ACLU attorney Jeanne Baker urged commissioners to read the organization's report dissecting racial and ethnic disparities in the county's justice system.
Advocates asked commissioners to dedicate funds to housing and education instead of new "cages."
"Jailing people in these institutions does not keep our communities safe," said Valencia Gunder, an activist and founder of Make the Homeless Smile.
Other speakers were opposed to the proposed location for the facility. A small bridge connects TGK to Virginia Gardens, and that community has complained for years about inmates released at night who wander about because they have no means of returning home.
"Please consider the human factor," Virginia Gardens Councilwoman Elizabeth Taylor-Martinez said. "As a former school counselor, I am asking that some consideration be made on the part of the county for the transportation of these individuals back to their home communities."
Gimenez committed to putting an end to that problem.
"We are making accommodations so that as individuals are released, they will go back to where they came from, and we will provide the transportation," the mayor said.
One physician raised eyebrows when she described the number of arrestees who come into jail with serious communicable diseases such as tuberculosis. Other members of the public urged commissioners to increase mental healthcare services for Miami-Dade inmates. Helen Peña, founder of the arts collective (F)empower, described how her sister, who has schizoaffective disorder, suffered for months without proper treatment while in pretrial detention.
"This is a personal matter to me," Peña said. "Twenty percent of Miami-Dade's inmates are in a mental health crisis."
Miami-Dade's existing jails are 30 to 60 years old and require significant improvements, according to the county. Corrections director Daniel Junior said building a new jail is necessary for the safety and health of inmates and staff.
"This is not about expansion," said Junior, who oversees the nation's eighth-largest jail system, with a daily population of 4,300 inmates. "This is about humane conditions for our residents."
And Junior directly addressed residents' concerns about suspicious activity by inmates released after hours.
"Virginia Gardens had only 35 suspicious calls in 2019," he said. Miami Springs, a small city that borders Virginia Gardens, had only four such calls last year.
However, no one at the meeting advocated for or spoke in favor of Gimenez's jail plans, and Commissioners Jose "Pepe" Diaz, Eileen Higgins, Jean Monestime, and Rebeca Sosa voted against accepting the mayor's report. The 4-4 tie vote came at the end of the nearly seven-and-a-half-hour meeting after some commissioners had already left.
"I understand that we need to do something," said Diaz, who has five detention facilities in his district. "But this is not the way. You have a bedroom community right on the other side."
Miami-Dade Deputy Mayor Jennifer Moon stressed that the jail plans are "just a report."
"It is simply the first step in moving forward to take some action to fix some of our facilities," she told meeting attendees.