Uber's Surge Prices Hit 9.9 Times the Normal Fare in Miami Beach During New Year's Eve

If there's one advantage traditional taxis have over Uber, it's that their rates always remain the same. That's not true for Uber. When the ratio of passengers requesting rides to the number of available drivers in an area becomes untenable, the "ride-sharing" app jacks up rates and informs riders they'll have to pay surge prices. 

Miami Beach is, of course, one of the hottest New Year's Eve destinations in the world, so it shouldn't be a surprise that the area would be affected by surge pricing on the busy night. However, surge pricing this weekend inflated so much that many users claimed on social media they had never seen such high rates before.

CNN media correspondent Brian Stetler was in Miami Beach for the holiday and found that when he tried to find a ride, the surge pricing hit 9.9 times the regular rate.  Other users were met with equally crazy surge price rates. 
Uber's surge pricing is one of the most controversial aspects of its business model. Though, the service has long defended the practice.

"We found that, without surge pricing, Uber is not really Uber — you can’t push a button and get a ride in minutes," the company said in a news release in September. 

The company says that people who don't want to pay surge pricing often end up waiting until fares decrease. Meanwhile, drivers from other nearby areas with less demand flock to the area affected by surge pricing in order to make more money. That's how it works in theory anyway. 

"Surge pricing has two effects: People who can wait for a ride often decide to wait until the price falls, and drivers who are nearby go to that neighborhood to get the higher fares," the company explains. "As a result, the number of people wanting a ride and the number of available drivers come closer together, bringing wait times back down."

That may work in everyday situations, but the system isn't quite built for a night like New Year's Eve in Miami. 

However, the 9.9 surge price isn't the highest ever recorded. In 2013, surge prices briefly hit 50 times the regular rate, though no one ended up accepting rides at that price

Surge prices over ten times the rate have been reported here and there, but many observers believe the 9.9 surge may now be the company's cap. Uber, however, has not confirmed that. 

Uber is technically illegal in Miami-Dade County but has remained operational while Mayor Carlos Gimenez tries to hammer out legislation that would legalize services such as Uber and its competitor Lyft.

The New York City Council is considering a law that would cap the amount Uber can charge customers under its surge pricing scheme
KEEP MIAMI NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started Miami New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Miami, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Kyle Munzenrieder