Scott Rothstein's work as a Mafia informant might help him in his Ponzi case

When fallen South Florida lawyer Scott Rothstein returned from Morocco last November after his Ponzi scheme blew up, he went straight into the womb of the federal government, where he immediately began working as an informant.

Rothstein, who talked his way into a $1.2 bogus investment scheme, would now try to talk his way out of life in prison.

Working out of a hotel room under the watch of federal agents, Rothstein wore a wire and began trying to make cases against former associates. The problem was, Rothstein was all over the South Florida media and had made national news as well. All signs pointed to the fact that Rothstein, although he was out of prison during November, was cooperating with the feds. Nobody could believe the government would allow the man who had committed perhaps the greatest economic crime in South Florida history to run free.


Scott Rothstein

Who could possibly be dumb enough to fall into such an obvious Rothstein trap?

Meet Roberto Settineri.

He's a stout and balding fellow from Palermo, Italy, who has lived in Miami for several years and has since become a naturalized U.S. citizen. State corporate records show he has owned several wine companies, but federal agents say he's a Sicilian Mafia associate who has played a key role as conduit between the Italian Mob and the New York-based Gambino and Colombo crime families that have extensive interests in South Florida.

Rothstein knew Settineri, apparently through a Fort Lauderdale-based company called Five Star Executive Protection & Security. After Rothstein bought a stake last year in Casa Casuarina, the former Versace mansion on South Beach, he brought Five Star in to do 24-hour security there. The company was owned by two Settineri associates, Enrique Ros of Miami and Daniel Dromerhauser of Pembroke Pines.

The feds were familiar with Settineri too. The New York FBI office was in the midst of a long-term investigation of a reputed Gambino Mob soldier and New York meat company owner named Gaetano Napoli. Last year, that investigation led agents to a "sit-down" in Pompano Beach among the 71-year-old Napoli, Settineri, and members of the Colombo crime family, according to federal prosecutors.

During the meeting, Settineri referenced his affiliation with the Sicilian Mob, piquing the FBI's interest in him. The problem was, they had no case on Settineri — that is, until Rothstein went to work.

After returning from Morocco, Rothstein contacted Settineri and Five Star's Ros and Dromerhauser. According to federal court documents, the sting was fairly simple: Rothstein told them he needed two boxes of financial documents destroyed and some Ponzi proceeds laundered.

The records were represented to have been subject to a federal grand jury subpoena involving the Rothstein Ponzi case. Settineri took the bait, according to the indictment, and in November received $79,000 in what he allegedly believed were Rothstein's ill-gotten gains.

Simultaneous to Rothstein's work and the New York FBI case against Napoli and his two sons, the Italian government was investigating Settineri's brethren in Palermo. The polizia's investigation centered on members of the Santa Maria di Gesù crime family and its alleged leaders, brothers Giacchino and Giampolo Corso.

March 10 was D-Day for all three prongs of the investigation. In Miami, federal agents say they arrested Settineri just before he was about to board a plane back to Italy. They also arrested Five Star's Dromerhauser. Ros initially couldn't be found but was arrested last week. All three have been charged with obstruction of justice for allegedly destroying the documents and conspiracy to commit money laundering.

Federal agents also picked up Napoli and his two sons, Thomas and Gaetano Jr., who happened to be in North Carolina. They were hit with a slew of charges related to threatening an alleged extortion victim, tampering with a grand jury witness, and lying in a bankruptcy case involving their New York business, Napoli & Sons Meats & Provisions.

Meanwhile, police in Palermo took down a total of 19 reputed members and associates of the Sicilian Mob crew, including the Corso brothers. Among the charges: drug trafficking, attempted murder, money laundering, and extortion.

Rothstein, meanwhile, remained behind bars on five Ponzi-related counts that could put him behind bars for 100 years. But his work on the Mafia case might ensure that we never again know where he is located.

In late February, the Ponzi schemer was transferred out of the Federal Detention Center in Miami and apparently relocated to the St. Lucie County Jail. The move was for his security before the announcement of the Mafia arrests.

He has since apparently been moved from the St. Lucie facility. It's speculated he has, or will be, put in the U.S. Witness Protection Program. Rothstein, who has already pleaded guilty, is scheduled for sentencing in May.

Questions abound, including just how much time U.S. District Judge James Cohn will hand down to Rothstein. In light of the Mafia case as well as his vast cooperation in the Ponzi case and potential law enforcement and public corruption cases, some speculate Rothstein might get a significant break.

The problem for those who want to see Rothstein pay dearly for his crimes is that now, no matter what sentence Cohn metes out, we might not be able to track him in the future. Rothstein will become a veritable ghost while the damage that he has caused South Florida will linger for years.

We use cookies to collect and analyze information on site performance and usage, and to enhance and customize content and advertisements. By clicking 'X' or continuing to use the site, you agree to allow cookies to be placed. To find out more, visit our cookies policy and our privacy policy.


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >