Under the guise of a crypto-zoologist, and in search of these elusive creatures, Butler created a website (icecreampeople.org), eliciting people to submit art work and other evidence of the beings' existence. Butler created a template of a cone and sent it to artists and children to fill in the blank scoop, which were then added to his "Gallery of Evidence." He hopes that one day, little children will be asking if ice cream people are real, adding to the Nessie, Bigfoot, and Skunk Ape mysteries. There were multiple "sightings" of these beings during Art Basel, cutouts made of cardboard, which lurked around gallery spaces, adding to the allure.