Katherine Fernandez Rundle, Miami's Top Prosecutor, Is a Disgrace
Miami-Dade County State Attorney's Office
Miami-Dade County has had the same prosecutor since Bill Clinton was president. Beginning in 1993, through the Clinton, Bush, Obama, and now Trump eras, she has not once charged a police officer for an on-duty killing.
What Katherine Fernandez Rundle, age 67, has done instead is make decades' worth of excuses for public officials accused of corruption and murder. When a Miami-Dade cop tasered a man to death, the officer wasn't charged. When a Miami-Dade cop was fired for shooting an unarmed black man, the officer walked free and was later rehired. When a group of cops lured robbers into the Redland and shot them on video, Rundle declined to charge the officers.
But now, in neglecting to charge the four prison guards who threw a black, schizophrenic inmate, Darren Rainey, into a scalding-hot shower for two hours until he died, Rundle has reached an all-time low.
Rundle's office announced its decision not to pursue charges in Rainey's case late Friday afternoon. The news dump was clearly designed to bury the story for the weekend and shield her from criticism. She should not be shielded. The facts of Rainey's case are grotesque: He was thrown into
Rainey was found dead, crumpled in a heap on the floor of the shower. Nurses who were interviewed at the time said that they saw red burns on his body and that Rainey's skin was peeling off.
Rundle, however, didn't believe testimony from nurses and inmates — and instead declined to bring charges against the four implicated guards. Citing an autopsy report (which claimed Rainey did not have burns on his body when he died) that has been criticized by the American Civil Liberties Union, Rundle announced Friday that the four state employees who forced a defenseless prisoner into a scalding shower until he died should go free.
The decision is just the latest in a long string of awful decisions by Rundle. Her office has made a living letting cops and county officials slide for questionable or downright criminal conduct. For one, the Miami Herald's 2015 investigation into state prisons, called "Cruel and Unusual," documented multiple cases in which inmates around the state were tortured, scalded with hot water or chemicals, and literally gassed to death. Though that series led to rule changes and firings, Rundle has not charged any prison guards involved in any prison-guard cases.
And that's just the jails. Here is a brief, and by no means comprehensive,
- In 2014, City of Miami Police Officer Reynaldo Goyos shot and killed an unarmed man at a traffic stop. Miami PD's then-chief called the shooting "unjustified," and a federal review of the department, based in part on Goyos' case, noted a "pattern of excessive force" at the department.
- In 2015, a Miami cop shot a homeless man in front of 50 children. The man was later identified as "nonviolent."
- Miami Police Union President Javier Ortiz doxxed and harassed a woman because she videotaped and stopped a Miami-Dade cop who was speeding in his patrol car.
- Officer John Hinson was repeatedly accused of beating up handcuffed subjects, including one incident that was caught on video.
- South Miami cop
AryoRezaie shot an unarmed former college football player, Michael Gavins, in the back. Gavins said he was simply standing next to the hood of a police cruiser.
- Miami Beach cops shot a man to death on Alton Road during Art Basel after they appeared to have confused the sound of Taser fire with gunfire.
- Miami Beach Det. Philippe Archer beat up a woman on camera and also a Good Samaritan who tried to stop the beating.
- Miami Beach Police tasered 18-year-old skater Israel "Reefa" Hernandez to death because he had tagged a building with graffiti.
- In 2015, officers from Miami Beach, Miami-Dade County, and Hialeah fired 100 bullets into a moving car, killing an innocent man.
- And, most astounding, Rundle refused to charge the cops involved in the so-called Redland shootings, in which a group of Miami-Dade cops carried out a military-inspired, ambush-style attack on an alleged armed mob, shot men on video, made conflicting statements to Rundle's office, and possibly tampered with evidence. The
cops in that casewere sued for what lawyers said was a pattern of luring suspects to staged crimes and "deliberately executing" them.
Granted, between 1989 and 2015, not a single Florida cop who had killed anyone while on duty had been charged with a crime. (Broward County Sheriff's Dep. Peter Peraza was accused in 2015 of manslaughter for admittedly killing 33-year-old Jermaine McBean, a computer engineer who was holding an unloaded air rifle and wearing earbuds. Peraza was allowed to use the state's deeply controversial "Stand Your Ground" law to walk free.) But that does not excuse Rundle's decision to effectively let corrupt or murderous city and county employees operate with impunity for three decades.
It's not just cops and prison guards: Rundle's office also bungled an investigation into blatantly corrupt former Miami congressman David Rivera, who was caught blowing more than $65,000 in campaign funds on personal items such as dental bills, pet care, and travel costs for his then-girlfriend. Rivera was once labeled the single most corrupt member of U.S. Congress, but Rundle's office claimed he somehow justified all the money he had spent because he was "continuously campaigning for more than a decade." Oh, and the State Attorney's Office claimed it was hampered by a two-year statute of limitations.
NPC Southern States Bikini, Figure, Men's Physique
TicketsFri., Jul. 7, 6:00pm
NPC Southern States Bodybuilding Championships vs. NPC Southern States Fitness & Figure Championships
TicketsSat., Jul. 8, 6:00pm
Florida Launch vs. Chesapeake Bayhawks
TicketsSat., Jul. 15, 7:00pm
Florida Launch vs. Charlotte Hounds
TicketsSat., Jul. 22, 7:00pm
So how has such an obviously inept and/or uncaring prosecutor kept a job for decades? By flying under the radar. In most big cities, the state or district attorney is constantly in the media — New York City tabloids devote entire stories to Manhattan DA Cyrus Vance Jr.'s Twitter photos, for example. The Philadelphia District Attorney's Office is the target of constant journalistic gossip and public scandal: Multiple members of DA Seth Williams' office were implicated in a porn-sharing scandal, and then Williams himself declined to run for reelection after getting caught taking unreported gifts. Williams had formerly been the sort of guy who gave vanity interviews to local city magazines for fun.
Nationally, prosecutors hold more power than judges. Prosecutors decide whether to accuse people of crimes and which charges will be leveled in court; judges simply rule on the decisions prosecutors make. A 2016 Fusion investigation found that the nation's state and district attorneys are disproportionately white, disproportionately male, and out of touch with the general public.
In Miami, however, the media rarely finds an excuse to print Rundle's name unless she's holding a news conference. The city's media outlets — New Times included — must do a better job of keeping constant pressure on Rundle for a series of lazy, unforced blunders and outright disgusting prosecutorial missteps.
Rundle has run virtually unopposed in each of her last three elections. (She has faced challenges from write-in candidates, but those barely count. Somehow, Miami's Police Benevolent Association has found reasons to oppose her more than once.) Added media pressure would turn the race for county prosecutor into the spectacle it ought to be. Until then, cops in Miami-Dade will continue to operate knowing full well they can kill people and get away with it.
Get the ICYMI: Today's Top Stories Newsletter Our daily newsletter delivers quick clicks to keep you in the know
Catch up on the day's news and stay informed with our daily digest of the most popular news, music, food and arts stories in Miami, delivered to your inbox Monday through Friday.