The city's pizza scene continues to evolve, with beachy newcomers, inventive pop-ups that have become mainstays, and old-school haunts that have become legendary for their classic pizza pies. Plus, one of the spots in this list, Heritage, just got a Michelin nod in the 2025 Florida Michelin Guide.
Here are 11 of New Times’ favorite pizza spots in Fort Lauderdale, listed in alphabetical order, to get your carb-craving journey started.
New Jersey's Blue Steel Pizza serves up Detroit-style pizza on Fort Lauderdale Beach.
Photo courtesy of Blue Steel Pizza
Blue Steel
849 Seabreeze Blvd., 103, Fort Lauderdalebluesteelpizzaftl.comIt's not every day you find legit Detroit-style pizza just steps from the sand, but Blue Steel is changing the game on Fort Lauderdale Beach. Square pies come with perfectly caramelized cheese edges and pillowy dough that strikes the right balance of crisp and chew. The "Sausage & Hot Honey" and "Bacon Chicken Ranch" pies are standouts, and its sleek, modern setup — tucked amid stalls at Marina Village — gives off hidden gem energy.
Heritage
903 NE Fifth Ave., Fort Lauderdale954-635-2335
heritageftl.comThis buzzy Flagler Village spot is where fine dining meets full-on pizza obsession. Chef Rino Cerbone's range of simplistic pies, like "the Bronx," a New York-style cheese pie, and the complex, like the "Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Bianco" equates to a Fort Lauderdale icon in the making. The dishes here are just as great as the pizza, even garnering the spot a Michelin recommendation in April of 2025. Plus, the restaurant's industrial-chic vibe and photo-popped walls round out the experience.
Louie Bossi
1032 E. Las Olas Blvd., Fort Lauderdale954-356-6699
louiebossi.comA Las Olas mainstay that's equal parts scene and substance, Louie Bossi isn’t just about the handmade pastas and sprawling patio. Its pizza menu leans rustic and Roman — with pies like the spicy salami-topped Piccante and Italian sausage-loaded Salsicce boasting a delightful mix of richness and freshness. Each pizza is fired to a crackling finish in their wood-burning oven, and the whole affair feels celebratory... even on a Tuesday.
Mister O1
415 NE 4th St., Fort Lauderdale754-253-5785
mistero1.comThis pizza chain may now be all over the map, but it got its humble start in Miami Beach. The Fort Lauderdale location stays true to the brand’s quirky identity with toppings like prosciutto di Parma, white truffle oil, and, yes, ever-controversial pineapple shaped into abstract art. Their crust is whisper-thin and perfectly blistered, built for those who appreciate creativity as much as authenticity. Pro tip: Order the Coffee Paolo as a buzzy surprise, which includes coffee and natural honey on top.
Moon Pizza Pie
3501 N. Dixie Hwy., Oakland Park954-533-3652
moonpizzapie.comTucked in the same building as Satellite Pinball Lounge, Moon Pizza Pie is a retro-cool joint dishing out serious slices in an unpretentious setting. It’s where old-school New York style meets playful experimentation: think the Mac Tonight with ground beef and a ketchup and mustard drizzle; or the meatball and ricotta-doused Out of Space. Whether you’re here for the games or the grub, you’re guaranteed a good time.
Patio Bar
901 Progresso Dr., Unit 114, Fort Lauderdalepatiobarpizza.comPizza, fire pits, and a funky industrial patio that feels plucked out of Wynwood — what more could you want? Patio Bar keeps the vibes high and the pies higher quality. Its soppressata and peppers number is rich and comforting, while the spicy Hawaiian packs a sweet-and-heat combo that’s hard to beat. Come for the pizza, stay for the laid-back live music and buzzy beer garden atmosphere.
Pizza Craft
330 Himmarshee St., Ste. 1, Fort Lauderdale954-616-8028
pizzacraftpizzeria.comPizza Craft is the kind of spot where everything is made in-house and with intention. Located on the edge of downtown’s Himmarshee nightlife strip, this pizzeria blends craft cocktails, wood-fired pies, and cozy patio seating for maximum appeal. Try the Spicy Soppressata with long hots if you're craving something bold and spicy, or go for the Fig Jam & Bacon concoction if you want a sweet touch to round things out.
Pizzeria Magaddino
1105 NE 13th St., Fort Lauderdale954-766-4842
pizzeriamagaddino.comThis low-key neighborhood gem inside of Gulf Stream Brewery flies under the radar but has built a cult following for its blistered, naturally leavened pies. Toppings are traditional yet top-shelf — from pepperoni cups to fresh basil — and there’s a hyper-focus on technique here that rivals some of the bigger names. Beyond the traditional, don’t be afraid to dabble in some of its more creative picks, including the Queen Bee with prosciutto and a chili-infused honey drizzle.
Primanti Bros.
901 N. Fort Lauderdale Beach Blvd., Fort Lauderdale954-565-0605
primantibros.comNo Fort Lauderdale pizza roundup is complete without a nod to Primanti's — the after-hours legend with Pittsburgh roots. Open late and steps from the sand, this no-frills, cash-only operation slings jumbo slices and monstrous sandwiches (with fries on them!) that are perfect for post-beach carb-loading. Grab a plain slice, fold it up like a local, and soak in the gritty charm that’s kept this place buzzing for decades.
Times Square Pizza
2304 E. Oakland Park Blvd., Fort Lauderdale954-566-7772
timessquarepizza.netBig, foldable, saucy, and satisfying — Times Square Pizza nails the New York-style pie without gimmicks or compromise. It’s a go-to for grab-and-go slices that don’t skimp on quality, and the prices are some of the most wallet-friendly in town (starting at $3.50). The garlic bread to its classic pepperoni have earned its local praise, while the thick AF Sicilian pie is an underrated sleeper hit. No frills, no fuss — just good pizza here.
Umberto's
3051 E. Commercial Blvd., Fort Lauderdale954-776-0258
umbertosfl.comA Fort Lauderdale staple for more than 30 years, Umberto's brings that classic Long Island Italian-American feel to East Commercial Boulevard. The simplistic brown tables, brick archways, and old-school menu (yes, they’ve got baked ziti, too) make it a nostalgic slice of New York in South Florida. Their pizza—especially that Meat Lover with big ole slices of ham—is crispy, cheesy, and deeply comforting. It’s the kind of pie that hits like a warm hug after a long day of South Florida craziness.
