Restaurants

Bertoni Caffe in Brickell Has a Secret Off-Menu Fried PB&J Sandwich

When it comes to snagging a secret menu item, one must be in the know. Because hidden dishes are scattered across various restaurants in town, finding off-menu items is a challenge. Sometimes, though, diners receive helpful information from the eatery itself.

Fork Yeah

Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Advertising Can't Do It Alone

The challenges facing local news organizations are very real. That's why reader support matters more than ever. If you believe independent journalism matters, make a contribution today and help us reach our summer fundraising goal of $10,000 by August 9.

$10,000

When it comes to snagging a secret menu item, one must be in the know. Because hidden dishes are scattered across various restaurants in town, finding off-menu items is a challenge. Sometimes, though, diners receive helpful information from the eatery itself.

Recently, NaiYaRa announced the existence of a fashionable sushi doughnut that is available only by asking a server.

Now, Bertoni Gelato Caffe in Brickell wants to share its own secret: a fried peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

“My favorite snack is peanut butter and jelly,” chef Eddie Baida says. “Sometimes I love to toast the bread so the peanut butter warms up a little, which is what made me think of frying it.”

Our dining newsletter is a tasty treat

Sign up now for free updates on openings, closings and all the food news that matters

Editor's Picks

Fork Yeah

Available by request, the warm sandwich smears all-natural peanut butter and Bertoni’s homemade blend of berry marmalade on classic white bread. Baida fries the treat to a crisp golden brown, keeping its doughy center intact. He coats the bread in tempura batter before frying it to prevent a mess and add crunch.

Before the dish is sent out, it’s drizzled with chocolate syrup and accompanied by a small scoop of gelato.

“To match the warmth of the sandwich, I decided to add a scoop of vanilla gelato,” he says. “It’s meant to dip and swirl your sandwich in.”

The sandwich costs $11.99, which is in line with the rest of Bertoni’s prices. Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the restaurant is known for fresh salads such as a kale blend topped with Parmesan, dates, and butternut squash, as well as pastas like sweet potato gnocchi and a variety of cheese- and meat-stuffed sandwiches. The PB&J is a welcome deviation from the restaurant’s otherwise health-focused menu.

Loading latest posts...