By Monique Jones
By Travis Cohen
By Liz Tracy
By Terrence McCoy
By Morgan Golumbuk
By Ciara LaVelle
By Carolina del Busto
By Michael E. Miller
As young Peggy, Gerlach sidesteps any attempt to present a balanced portrayal, instead seizing Mastrosimone's one-dimensional conniver and playing her to the hilt. As both the spoiled pet who scorns her father's advice to flirt with soldiers from both camps and the woman who fakes hysteria to save herself from a charge of treason, Gerlach provides the production's rare captivating moments. On the other hand, given little to do but carry her husband's coat, Olsen's solemn, defeated, elder Peggy bears little resemblance to the firebrand of her youth.
The remainder of the cast deserves commendations of valor: Owens's comic timing pays off in his depiction of Peggy's father and various dignitaries; Newfield's upper-crust prissiness upholds our preconceptions about royalists; Hilliard invests generals Washington and Clinton with the right amount of war-weary realism; Kevin Blake nails the disillusioned cynicism of the impoverished rebel army's young soldiers and couriers; and Tarallo hits a realistic note as Arnold's loyal subordinate. Yet the play's perpetually shifting time lines and the necessity for exposition to set up historical events ultimately work against the economies of doubling roles, making it difficult, for example, to tell Hilliard's generals apart.
Adding to the confusion is Jim Fulton's dreamlike shadowy lighting for the play's later setting and his choice of bright vistas for the earlier years; these peg the temporal shifts but fail to assist in explaining the significance of the elder Arnolds' haphazard time travels. Similarly, Michael Amico's minimal set of tables and chairs placed before a background of eighteenth-century war artifacts solves the technical problem of accommodating scenes that take place over twenty years on two different continents, but it stops short of investing any one setting with a distinctive feel. Finally, as for Mark Pirolo's functional costumes, at least the red and blue coats help us to distinguish the Brits from the Americans.
Given two plays to direct -- one in which a young man turns against his country and one filled with that same man's later regrets -- J. Barry Lewis imparts a definite rhythm to each, contrasting the straightforward thrust of the Revolutionary War era against the slower-paced tentative gloom of Arnold's final years. Distressingly, though, Lewis never consolidates the two to produce one unified theatrical experience. Then again, working from Mastrosimone's script, how could he? An award-winning playwright (Los Angeles Drama Critics Award for The Woolgatherer, New York Critics Circle Award for Extremities) as well as a successful television writer (the Sinatra miniseries, The Burning Season), Mastrosimone delivers a cinematic script instead of one crafted for the stage. Camerawork, a soundtrack, and clever editing could translate the story's doppelgängers, vague historical sketches, and sweeping scenes into a comprehensible tale. For the theater, however, where the audience serves as both cameraman and editor and must decide what to focus on, Mastrosimone's script lacks the visual and verbal clues necessary to create a memorable dramatic impact.
Written by William Mastrosimone; directed by J. Barry Lewis; with Dan Leonard, Bob Rogerson, Alana J. Gerlach, Joanna Olsen, Anthony Newfield, Ryan Hilliard, Michael George Owens, Barry Tarallo, and Kevin Blake. Through November 30. For more information call 561-585-3433, 800-514-3837, or see "Calendar Listings.