Audio By Carbonatix
Anyone who has been following the restaurant wars between
Philippe and Mr. Chow will not be surprised to see that both gourmet Chinese
restaurants have many of the same dishes on their menus. Probably
the most popular item at each eatery is the chicken satay, a presentation of
skewered chicken served with peanut sauce. Although Philippe has been open
longer in Miami Beach, Mr. Chow actually invented this appetizer after its
debut in 1968 in London.
Going head-to-head for this chicken satay competition was an
easy task considering the restaurants are next door to one another. Short Order
began at the Gansevoort South Hotel (where Philippe resides) and then headed
a block south to the W Hotel (where Mr. Chow recently set up camp). Below are the
results of our taste test.
Philippe’s Chicken
Satay ($18 for three skewers)
Pros: Arriving on a white plate, the trio of chicken was drizzled with the
chef’s “famous cream sauce.” This peanut-cream condiment was a nice counterpart
to the lengthy chicken strips, and there was a generous pool of sauce on the bottom
of the plate for dipping. The orange coating was firm and even.
Cons: The satay
could have been hotter; it arrived lukewarm. The color was shockingly orange, and permeating the satay was an odd, tangy
flavor, which, although it was not unpleasant, Short Order could not identify.
Mr. Chow’s Chicken
Satay ($5.50 per skewer)
Pros: The
“original recipe” appetizer was served piping-hot and was accompanied with a
good sauce-to-skewer ratio. The color of the coating was a muted orange, which
is more pleasing to the eye. An bonus component, Mr. Chow’s chili sauce, added
heat to the skewers in a favorable way.
Cons: The skewers
are smaller than the ones at Philippe. It’s definitely a more petite serving of
chicken. The taste is bland, although the addition of the aforementioned chili
sauce perked the dish up.
Verdict: It was
very close, but the edge went to Mr. Chow’s satays. Not only were they served
hotter, but also the accompanying spicy condiment made the dish that more
interesting. Short Order just couldn’t get past the tangy aftertaste or lukewarm temperature of
Philippe’s version.
Philippe
305-674-0250
2305 Collins Ave., Miami Beach
Mr. Chow
305-696-1695
2201 Collins Ave., Miami Beach
