About a year ago, pharmacy chain CVS and its Pembroke Pines employee Lisa Conteh were named in one of South Florida's most bizarre lawsuits. Outlets from MSNBC to Univision reported that Conteh was accused of accosting and trapping a 13-year-old girl in the pharmacy's bathroom -- and then forcing her to prove she didn't steal a sanitary pad by showing Conteh the one she was wearing.
But now deposition in the ongoing trial suggests that Conteh didn't force the girl to expose herself after all. According to the girl, male police officers did. Conteh, meanwhile, claims the false accusation is ruining her life.
The teenager's Miami-based attorney, Spencer Aronfeld, stands by his client's claim that she was accosted by Conteh -- but admits the suit has been bruising for both sides. "It's World War III," Aronfeld says. "It's a 13-year-old girl against the eighth largest corporation in America."
The girl, who is unnamed because she's a minor, and her mother filed suit in April 2010. The complaint claimed that Conteh, a cashier, "assaulted" the girl and "dragged her" into the bathroom. News reports citing Aronfeld claim that, as NBC Miami put it, the employee forced the girl "to take off the pad she was wearing and show it to Conteh."
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to Miami New Times's mission. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Miami's stories with no paywalls.
Support Our Journalism
But in a December 2011 deposition, the girl contradicted that account. Asked if it was a "misstatement" that a CVS employee made her show her pad, the girl answered simply: "Yes." When CVS's and Conteh's attorney, Aleida Mielke, asked, "It was the police that asked you to show your pad, right?" the girl again answered, "Yes."
Says Aronfeld: "I don't think she recanted her testimony. There's no conflict in the testimony that [Conteh] grabbed her in the bathroom." He then adds that CVS can add Pembroke Pines police to the lawsuit if the corporation desires.
Conteh could not be reached at the CVS where she apparently still works. But her attorneys are hoping to throw out the case, declaring that "Lisa has been falsely accused and maligned in the local and national media."