Just like that previous album, Happy Music for Happy People finds Mogwai using whatever technological tools or dynamics are necessary to marry rock's aggression with compositional form. But despite brief moments of transcendence, the group ultimately fails to wrap its impressive technical chops around significant human emotion. Despite the crash and thunder it generates, nothing but a temporary awe remains after it subsides.
That said, Mogwai definitely deserves props for refusing to retreat into obvious stadium-rock theatrics that would otherwise submerge the material in clichés. The screeching walls of noise they evoke on "Killing All the Flies" and "Stop Coming to My House" show that guitarists Stuart Braithwaite and John Cummings know enough about their instruments to overpower any modern rock act content to prepackage teen rebellion. "I Know You Are But What Am I?" indicates that Radiohead isn't the only group that can integrate IDM-style electronics into its repertoire without sacrificing its sonic identity. But the somber, high-minded mood and tone of Mogwai's sound hasn't really changed much, which may make some people happy but cause others to wonder about the group's limitations.