Florida International University photo
Audio By Carbonatix
Keep Miami New Times Free
We’re aiming to raise $7,500 by April 26. Your support ensures New Times can continue watching out for you and our community. No paywall. Always accessible. Daily online and weekly in print.
A Florida International University (FIU) student was arrested on Thursday for allegedly requesting in a WhatsApp group chat, in what she later called a “dumb joke,” that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu drop a bomb on a campus building before capstone project presentations.
According to the FIU Police arrest report obtained by New Times, Gabriela Saldana “made a threat to kill or do bodily harm to individuals regarding a scheduled event” planned for Friday. The 23-year-old student who admitted to sending the messages in the 200-person chat was charged with written threats to kill or do bodily injury with prejudice, the arrest report states.
A screenshot of the message circulating on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, states, “Netanyahu, if you can hear me, drop some bonbons for us capstone students in Ocean Bank Convention Center.” An FIU police officer also claimed in bond court that Saldana wrote, “There is going to be a bomb in the Ocean Bank Convocation Center, and it is going to be @Jonathan’s fault.” Jonathan, according to police, was a member of the group chat.
Saldana’s arrest came one day after the messages were allegedly sent.
In the fallout of Saldana’s arrest, FIU students and Instagram users have pointed out the discrepancies between how this incident has been handled versus the group chat where students used racist slurs, discussed dozens of ways of violently killing Black people, and advocated for “Total negro death.”
“And the what about the racist group chat with death threats?” a comment reads on WSVN’s (Channel 7) Instagram post. “That’s not probable cause?”
Another added, “Why they ain’t do this for the TPUSA gc?? 😂”
The university’s investigation into the members of the racist group chat appears to be ongoing.
None of the students from the group has faced expulsion or suspension since the messages were leaked nearly six weeks ago, according to the Miami Herald earlier this month. Students on campus have expressed frustration with the university’s handling of the messages. Meanwhile, another group of students is facing potential student conduct violations for protesting the university’s partnership with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
A user responded, “So what about the other group chat?”
Others questioned whether Saldana’s comment constituted an arrestable offense.
Lawyer Jack Palmeri wrote, “From a criminal defense perspective, the ‘Nentanyahu request’ seems too far fetched to be reasonably taken seriously.”
A spokesperson for FIU did not respond to New Times‘ requests for comment via email and text message. Saldana’s public defender declined to comment.
In an interview with New Times, Charlotte Arneson, program officer of campus rights advocacy for the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, or FIRE, says in her view the university should not have intervened in either case — the Netanyahu comment or the racist chat.
“The First Amendment protects talking about violence, descriptions, glorification, and hyperbolic speech about violence,” she adds. “It certainly protects jokes and jokes about or directed at state leaders.”
She warns that these decisions can be viewed as arbitrary and have a chilling effect on protected speech.
“You don’t know now what speech is going to be punished or not, and when or if it’s going to be punished, so it makes people more afraid and more likely to self-censor,” She tells New Times.
