This week, Miami New Times is publishing a guide to the eight of the worst public works projects in Miami-Dade, where bureaucrats and elected officials take pride in wasting millions in taxpayer dollars on crap residents have little-to-no use for. As we reveal each one of these boondoggles on Riptide, we're asking readers to send us their suggestions of the most asinine things local government has built in your neighborhoods. We'll pick the best one and send the winner a seven-day pass to try out the wonderfully terrible public bus and rail system provided by Miami-Dade Transit. Leave your suggestions in the comments or email them to Banana Republican. Enjoy!
Today, we drive through the emptiest taxpayer-funded parking lot in Miami-Dade.
Miami Gardens Park-and-Ride Lot
Year built: 2011
Cost: $1.8 million
What's dumb about it: Motorists rarely park at the lot to ride a Metrobus.
Why it was built: To persuade drivers to abandon their cars for the public transit system.
a balmy morning this past November 1. Bernardo Rodriguez peddles a
red BMX bicycle on busy NW 73rd Avenue at Miami Gardens Drive past a
chainlink fence with a banner that reads, "Park & Ride Lot now
open, serving bus routes 73, 99, 183, and 286." One sedan, a truck,
and a rusty station wagon are the only vehicles in the 150-space lot.
here," he says. "Ever." During an hour that New
Times spends at the lot during rush hour, a total of four people show up.
2006, taxpayers shelled out $1.8 million for the two-acre lot. It was
supposed to persuade neighbors in this moderately affluent suburban
neighborhood to abandon their vehicles and ride public transit to
Aventura or Dadeland. A new express bus could even take them to the
Palmetto Metrorail station or southwest Broward County.
took five years to complete the project. Since July, when it opened,
the lot has been virtually empty. The $1.8 million provides for an
average of 36 riders per day, county records show. That's about $72
per day in fares, meaning it will take somewhere around 70 years to
repay the expense, even if you don't account for the cost of buses.
And that express bus to Broward? Killed due to budget cuts.
just went up, out of the blue," says Barbara Hagen, a Country Club of Miami homeowner. "The only people I have seen
parking there go to the IHOP next to it." She and several neighbors
protested the county's use of the two acres for a parking lot when
the issue arose in 2006. "The transit department assured us the lot
was going to serve the area near I-75 that was being developed,"
she says. "If they had express buses going to the airport and
seaport in Fort Lauderdale or going to Naples, the lot would make
sense. That would be revolutionary. But they don't."
Transit spokeswoman Karla Damien explains it took six years to build
the lot because Florida Power & Light had to approve building the lot on top of underground electrical utilities and nearby power lines.
the Miami Gardens lot is the second-worst performing of 11
park-and-ride bus facilities that the transit agency operates.
Thirty-six riders board buses here each day compared to the 2,107 who
use the Golden Glades Interchange lot, nine miles away. The agency
does not break down how many of those riders actually arrive in a
vehicle. The worst one, by the way, is located at Kendall Drive and SW 150th Avenue.,
with only 15 riders a day.
Miami Gardens spot could be a park or maybe used for YMCA parking
overflow. "Right now, it's useless," Hagen says.
Guide to Trashing Taxpayers:
Keep Miami New Times Free... Since we started Miami New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Miami, and we would like to keep it that way. Offering our readers free access to incisive coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with gutsy reporting, stylish writing, and staffers who've won everything from the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with local journalism's existence under siege and advertising revenue setbacks having a larger impact, it is important now more than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Miami with no paywalls.