Opening Friday at Coral Gables Art Cinema, Meek's Cutoff, like all of director Kelly Reichardt's previous features (River of Grass, Old Joy, Wendy and Lucy), is essentially a road movie about both the unequal distribution of power and resources and the frustrations of the disenfranchised.
Tracking three hungry and thirsty families on the long wagon journey from Missouri to Oregon in the mid-19th century who are lost because of the poor navigational skills of their wild-man hired guide, Stephen Meek (Bruce Greenwood), the film is based on extensive research by Reichardt, who grew up in Miami, and screenwriter Jon Raymond. They adapted many details from the journals of women who trekked with the real-life Meek, who disastrously led a splinter group off the Oregon Trail.
"Meek was perceived in different ways by different people, but
definitely was thought of as someone who didn't know what he was doing
by pretty much everyone," Reichardt says, sharing a couch in a
Williamsburg production office with her dog, Lucy, co-star and
co-namesake of her last feature.
Meek's own 14-page autobiography, she
explains, wasn't much help: "Ten pages is this long-winded joke, and
then he's just like, 'I led the first wagon train through Oregon
territory. Completely successful.' Probably just like George W. Bush's
new book: 'Everything went great. Not to worry.'"
Meek's Cutoff is set in 1845, the same year that Margaret Fuller
published her foundational feminist text Woman in the Nineteenth
Century. Fuller, a dedicated transcendentalist who advocated female
self-reliance and equality between spouses, wrote that the highest form
of marriage constituted a "pilgrimage towards a common shrine."
Fuller's notions are manifest in Meek's female lead, Emily Tetherow
(Michelle Williams), the tough and determined wife of the party's
captain, Soloman. Extraordinarily self-sufficient compared with the
other women on the journey (played by Shirley Henderson and Zoe Kazan),
Emily enjoys enough parity with her husband that he gives her recaps of
the tense debates among the men. And she's the only member of the party
bold enough to articulate everyone's fear concerning Meek: "Is he
ignorant? Or is he just plain evil?"
Reichardt's film has been called a revisionist Western due to its
emphasis on women and the empathy shown for an Indian (Rod Rondeaux)
rather than the cowboy Meek. But the director's interest in dismantling
the conventions of the genre goes further than simply swapping one
perspective for another.
"The Western as we've come to know it is so much about these exploding,
heightened moments. And then you read these women's journals and you're
like, 'Oh, it's like a trance!' [They're] really a list of chores,"
Reichardt explains. "'Built the fire, popped the tent, made the bread,
walked eight miles.' It's the opposite of heightened moments. It's about
monotony and labor, one day melting into the next." To underscore the
settlers' disassociation from time and space, Reichardt uses long, slow
dissolves as they endlessly trudge across terrain that all looks the
The women's perception of the landscape is constrained by their bonnets,
which are large enough to cover their ears and block out peripheral
vision. Reichardt shot the film in the square, 1.33:1 aspect ratio to
replicate this limited perspective and to heighten the sense of
claustrophobic immediacy. "Jon would put in the script, 'And then
they're surprised by...' And I'm like, 'Jon, what surprise? Standing in
the desert, I can see for 40 miles. I can be shocked by nothing.' So how
do you create this space where you could still come upon something
[unexpected]? The square helped me with that--you wouldn't see tomorrow
or yesterday in the shot."
Meek's is Reichardt's largest-scale project to date. "Compared to the
last movie that we made," says Williams, referring to 2008's Wendy and
Lucy, in which she also starred, "we were rolling in cash! But there was
so much more for it to cover." The low-budget shoot was almost as
grueling and resource-challenged as the journey it depicted.
is the great equalizer," Reichardt notes wryly. Cast and crew all
stayed at the Horseshoe Motel in Burns, Oregon, a two-hour drive on
dusty, unpaved roads from the film's desolate locations. "If you're
Bruce Greenwood, you're staying in the same kind of room as the driver
who's working on a film for the first time," the director adds.
Even though the crew members struggled to make do with very little, they
were still injecting money into an even more dire economy in the
business- and industry-deficient Burns--population, 3,020. "I thought,
What will it be like going to this little Republican town?" Reichardt
recalls. Yet instead of small-town small-mindedness, the production was
warmly greeted. "There was really high unemployment, and we were able to
hire locals, like ranchers and auto-repair men."
The interrelated struggles of the movie's characters, its cast and crew,
and the locals who supported the production--most of whom claimed to be
descendants of the members of the real Meek party--call to mind Jacques
Rivette's observation that every film is a documentary of its own
making. Essentially, the people of Burns were helping Reichardt's crew
make a feature about their own past that also, politically and
economically, reflects the struggles of the present, not only in their
town but also in the realm of micro-budgeted film.
But as much as the limitations of the shoot may have contributed a sense
of realism to the finished product, "it doesn't need to be quite as
hard," Reichardt says. "I don't want to make another film as stretched
as we were."
The title Meek's Cutoff becomes almost literal in its last scene, when
the arrogant guide's power is apparently curtailed, the dominance of the
American cowboy upended. The moment offers such a bold punctuation to
the film's foundational ideas that it's surprising to hear that it came
together at the last minute, when the production ran out of money.
would like it so that, if the sun's going to set, you're not going home
without the ending of your movie," Reichardt says. "[But that's]
basically what happened to us: The sun went down, everyone was leaving
the next day, and we couldn't afford the animals another day. So a new
ending had to be constructed. Michelle, Rod, and I went back with a
five-person crew and shot it."
The compromises necessitated by financial constraints have been a theme
in both Reichardt's films and her own career trajectory. She recalls the
frustrations that followed her breakout at the 1994 Sundance Film
Festival, where River of Grass premiered alongside Kevin Smith's Clerks
and David O. Russell's Spanking the Monkey--films that turned those two
directors into hot commodities. But Reichardt says "the door wasn't
open" to her in the same way. More than a decade passed between River of
Grass and Old Joy (2006), during which time she taught and made
experimental shorts. She still makes her living teaching at Bard
"It feels like the kind of thing I'm doing--shooting film, projecting in
theaters--is a sinking ship, for sure," the maverick filmmaker says. But
she finds some consolation when she returns to the idea of duress as a
If you like this story, consider signing up for our email newsletters.
SHOW ME HOW
You have successfully signed up for your selected newsletter(s) - please keep an eye on your mailbox, we're movin' in!
leveler: "However it's going to change, maybe the bright side of that is
that it'll be an equalizer. It'll bring in more voices, more variety."
Coral Gables Art Cinema's Miami premiere of Meek's Cutoff at 7 p.m Friday will be followed by a reception, featuring "Old West-style" Dewar's mixed drinks and food by Chef Allen. There will also be live traditional fiddle music from the Old Time Jammers, and Director of the Coral Gables Museum Arva Moore Parks will introduce the film. Opening night tickets cost $15. Visit gablescinema.com.