Eat Horse Meat, Spend a Year in a Florida Jail (Updated)
Last year, somebody
killed and ate Ivonne Rodriguez's quarter horse, Geronimo.
that somebody tries the same thing next year, he will likely spend at
least a year in jail and pay a $3,500 fine. The Florida House of
Representatives is poised to pass a bill making it a felony to traffic
in illegal horse meat. They're calling it the Ivonne Rodriguez Horse
"My horse had been tied to a palm tree and
slaughtered," Rodriguez wrote in 2009.
"This is something that has to be stopped." (So far there have been no
I don't like the bill
much. Sure, Florida regulators have passed the buck on regulating horse
butchery. In the '90s, they assigned regulation to the feds, who
dropped the ball. And it is a tragedy that Rodriguez's beauty, Geronimo, was cut up and buried under a bunch of palm fronds. There were at least
19 others thus whacked last year in South Florida.
But mandatory minimum sentences are no good. Judges ought to be able
to decide how to penalize bad guys. And the new bill -- which is almost
certain to pass the House but could hang up in the Senate -- adds
"transporting, distributing, purchasing, or possessing" as crimes.
Businesses would lose their licenses for selling the stuff.
"This isn't like drugs; you don't get addicted to horse meat," says Florida Rep. Luis Garcia, a Democrat who represents
much of Central Miami-Dade and is sponsoring the bill in the House. "This is one crime where if we attack the demand, we just might lessen the crime."
He adds the bill has
been amended to regulate treatment of polo ponies
too. It's now ready to be voted on by the full House and has been
approved by one Senate committee. Good politics, but who in hell eats
I mean, really, in South Florida, perhaps the
nation's most cosmopolitan area, people eat this stuff. It should
certainly be better regulated. But this law won't do the trick. Better
enforcement will -- and money so that cops and committed folks, such as the SPCA's Laurie Waggoner,
can investigate nasty killings when they happen.
Still, you have
to like the way Garcia talks about he problem. "In the old West, they used to
hang people for this," he says. "I don't want to sound like Clint Eastwood, but I say, 'Hang 'em high.' "
Get the Dining Newsletter
The week's top local food news and events, plus interviews with chefs and restaurant owners, dining tips, and a peek at our print review.