Say What?

Max Bemis, frontman for the New York-based band Say Anything, was diagnosed three years ago as bipolar. This, he says, made absolute sense — it explained his manic episodes. In fact he attributes the lyrics of the band's 2004 debut, ... Is a Real Boy, to the disorder.

If that weren't enough, around the time that album dropped, he was also trying to survive a volatile breakup with his first love. It was an experience that, along with his diagnosis, drove him to check into to a mental hospital. When the transplanted Los Angeleno finally came up for air, with his life put back together, he hauled his band into the studio to record the followup to its much-lauded debut.

The result: In Defense of the Genre, a double-disc concept album that pretty much is the definition of autobiographical. It's so audaciously ambitious that even Bemis can't take it entirely seriously.


Max Bemis|Say Anything

Say Anything, Hellogoodbye, and Polysics perform as part of the MySpace Music Tour Wednesday, November 7, at the Fillmore Miami Beach, 1700 Washington Ave, Miami Beach. The show starts at 7:00 p.m., and tickets cost $21.50. Visit

We chatted with him recently and only in retrospect realized our goal to get him to, um, say anything to words related to his life and career also seemed strangely like a Rorschach test. It was a complete coincidence, given his bipolarity. But Bemis didn't appear to mind, and dealt out nothing but unhesitatingly honest, revealing answers to our battery of prompts.

Sophomore albums.

Pressure. But I'm proud of it.


How I prefer things to be.


Neurotic frontman.


The Devil.


Pretty irrelevant classifications.


Means as much as the term rock and roll does.

Concept album.

Any good album should be strung together in some way.

Rock star.

A subjective term.


Powerful, and you have to be selective about them.

Indie rock.

Doesn't mean the same thing anymore.


They're varied, with various levels of loyalty and substance.


Change as you get older, and you figure out what you have.

Love story.

A common thread through all humanity.


Regret, complete isolation.


A good thing, but only in healthy doses.

Freddie Mercury.

Probably the best singer of all time.


My pills help me get through the day. It's not so much that I'm sedated; it's so I feel like I always do.


Part of my spiritual basis, but it doesn't encompass my whole spiritual being.


Not something negative.

Los Angeles.

Beautiful weather and a lot of vacuous people.

New York.

Same deal, except the weather's not as good.


They're fun.


Like musicians, some of them are in it for the right reasons, some of them are in it for the wrong reasons.

Saves the Day.

My favorite band.


A useful tool, but it has its drawbacks and unnecessary subcultures.

Lloyd Dobler.

A character I relate to very closely.

Max Bemis.



All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >