Search More

Locations

Rusty Pelican

3201 Rickenbacker Causeway Key Biscayne, FL 33149 | Key Biscayne | 305-361-3818

Location Description:

After all is said about the Rusty Pelican's $7 million renovation, the waterfront view from every seat -- whether through clear bay windows or from outdoor tables illuminated by fire pits -- still steals the show. The menu is contemporary American (implying a global influence) and, rather surprisingly, not very seafood-centric -- in fact, except a few shellfish offerings, main-course fish choices encompass only local sea bass, local red snapper, and Columbia River salmon (which is rolled with foie gras). If you choose to have a fish straightforwardly grilled, it's down to just salmon or sea bass. Be that as it may, seafood lovers have options. Starters include a handful of sushi and sashimi selections, lobster crudo, sea scallop tiradito, fried calamari, ahi tuna tacos, and sea bass ceviche. The last, served in an oval tin set in crushed ice, lavishes luscious chunks of sea bass tossed with choclo corn kernels, red onion, small cubes of sweet potato, cilantro, lime juice, and aji amarillo -- which yields a nice bite in the back of the throat. Black sea bass fillets and fried whole red snapper were fresh and satisfying anchors to main-course plates, but sides on both were disappointing. Poached Long Island duck breast -- served as three sushi-size cylinders that were tender, juicy, and boasting rich duck flavor -- was the only real eye-opener we sampled. Desserts include a thin rectangular slice of key lime pie and baked Alaska with a soft, fresh cap of bronzed meringue over rock-hard cookies-and-cream ice cream. So much about the Rusty Pelican has changed, but the only real rationale for dining here remains, as always, the view.


Related Stories (39)

Details

  • Cuisine(s): Continental, Seafood
  • Hours: Sun-Thu 11am-11pm, Fri-Sat 11am-12am
  • Price: $$$$
  • Serving: Breakfast, Dinner, Lunch
  • Alcohol: Full bar
  • Reservations: Accepted, Required
  • Parking: Lot Available, Valet
  • Payment Types: All Major Credit Cards, cash
  • Attire: Casual
  • Extra Info: Smoking permitted on outside patio only. On July 5th, 2011 this restaurant will be temporarily closed due to renovations.
  • Features: Banquet Facilities, Catering, Kid Friendly, Multi-Level, Patio/Sidewalk Dining, Water View, Wheelchair Accessible

Upcoming Events

  • Happy Hour

    10:30 p.m. every Mon., Tue., Wed., Thu., Fri., Sat.
  • #WCW

    Every Wed.
  • #BFF

    Every Fri.

Related Stories

  • Short Order: Best of Miami
    Yesterday's late afternoon thunderstorm might have looked threatening, but by the time last night's Best Of celebration at the Rusty Pelican in Key Biscayne started, there was a rainbow...
  • Calendar: Highlights
    You’re holding the 2014 Miami New Times Best of Miami issue in your hands right this second. Isn’t it exciting? Does it make you want to dance? Are you inspired to celebrate? If...
  • Short Order: Best of Miami
    While you're on your way to the office, be sure to pick up Miami New Times' 27th annual Best of issue, which hits the streets today, June 19. Sure, you've been reading it online, but this is...
  • Short Order: Booze Hound
    New Times' 27th annual Best of Miami issue hits the street on June 19, naming more than 400 of the best places to shop, eat, drink, and party in our fair city. We can't wait to share with...
  • Calendar: Highlights
    There’s something supersexy about Peruvian food. Even the dishes’ monikers have a certain sensuality — “ceviche” sounds way better than “marinated...
  • Short Order: Booze Hound
    What are the two best words in the English language? No, not "free money" (although we'll take that). It's "happy hour." For us workers of the world, happy hour is the one thing we have to...
  • Short Order: Best of Miami
    The day you've been waiting for is coming. New Times' 27th annual Best of Miami issue hits the street on June 19, naming more than 400 of the best places to shop, eat, drink, and party in...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    Mother's Day is this Sunday, May 11. It's payback time. Payback for all the laundry and cleaning. Payback for the meals she made for your lazy self. Payback for those twenties she peeled out...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    Valentine's Day is this Friday, February 14 and if you haven't made your dinner reservations, we suggest you stop whatever you're doing and get on that! Luckily, just about every restaurant...
  • Crossfade: Photos
    It's awesome to be a VIP. Even if it only lasts a day. Over the weekend, Brisk Bodega lined up a prime party schedule, from lunch with DJ Irie to an American Airlines Arena VIP suite at...
  • Short Order: Food Charity
    The Peruvian-American Chamber of Commerce will be presenting the third Peru Gourmet Festival next Tuesday, showcasing both the food and drink of the South American country. Marisol Chocano...
  • Short Order: Because It's Free
    Free eats, free drinks and Instagram filters are pretty much a trifecta of awesome. But add the chance to make our metropolis a better place, and it becomes fourfecta (is that a thing?)....
  • Short Order: Celebites
    It looks as though Miami is officially the second home of Mob Wives. First, Angela "Big Ang" Raiola opened an outpost of her Staten Island bar, the Drunken Monkey, on South Beach. Miami...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    Fourth of July means firing up the grill out back and hanging with family, unless you're more into the whole barbecue bash with interesting-people-in-fascinating-places thing, Short Order...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    While the rest of Miami hurries to Publix and Fresh Market for last minute shopping lists, the smart people of this good city will stare good and hard at this list -- and with just a quick...
  • Short Order: Iron Fork
    Thousands of hungry and thirsty people converged upon Grand Central Miami last evening to eat, drink and be merry at New Times' fifth annual Iron Fork.  Over three dozen of Miami's...
  • Short Order: Best of Miami
    Want access to our Best Of picks from your smartphone? Download our free Best Of app for the iPhone or Android phone from the App Store or Google Play. Don't forget to check out the full...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    It's true that where fireworks are concerned, there's not a bad seat in the house. After all, you're looking up at the night sky -- usually from a beach or a boat. But with so many cities...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    Fourth of July can either be the most memorable night of the year, or your biggest headache. Every year in Miami, numerous dazzling displays of patriotism explode in the horizon, while...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    The fourth July comes out on a hump day this year, which means a perfect break in the work week in which to celebrate our nation's break from imperial rule. Miami, being a party town, has a...
  • Short Order: Happy Hour Hunt
    After the Miami Heat won the championships last night, the team celebrated  at LIV, where the boys ran up a $200,000 bar tab. If you want to celebrate the team's win (but are finding...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    Moms come in all shapes and sizes, and Miami restaurants offer meals  to suit every type.  We've compiled a list of restaurants serving up special meals for Mother's Day... by mom...
  • Short Order: Best of Miami
    We are dedicated to saving Scotty's Landing, one of the city's best venues with a view, so even though we named the best places for brew with a view last month -- Scotty's was number four --...
  • Short Order: Review
    Executive chef Michael Gilligan is at the helm of the new kitchen at the landmark Rusty Pelican on the Rickenbacker Causeway. The $7 million in recent renovations include a...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    In honor of Administrative Professionals Day (say that three times fast), numerous establishments are providing quick escapes for those backbones of our offices. Waterfront lunches with...
  • Short Order: Favorite Dishes
    It's that time of year when we count down to New Times' Best of Miami 2012 issue in June. Until then, Short Order will serve up 100 of our favorite dishes in the 305. If you have any...
  • Short Order: Holidays
    We're not sure just when the tradition of stuffing your face like a crazy person on ham, roast beef, colored eggs, and copious amounts of baked goods started -- but we like it just the same....
  • Dining: Reviewed
    Until a recent $7 million makeover, the Rusty Pelican was becoming a musty Pelican. All of that work has freshened up the joint, but there was something cozy and unpretentious about the old...
  • Short Order: Review
    Until a recent $7 million makeover, the Rusty Pelican was becoming a musty Pelican. All of that work has freshened up the joint, but there was something cozy and unpretentious about the old...
  • Short Order: First Bites
    Right off the bat, we have a confession: We never ate at the former Rusty Pelican before the recent remodeling. We feared it would be musty inside and found it an ordeal to trek out to...
  • Dining: Reviewed
    Less than a decade ago, Miami had arguably the worst dining scene of any famous city in America. If you wanted a great meal back then, you were better off heading to Ohio. (Seriously,...
  • Short Order: Chef Interviews
    They may have kept the old name, but everything else at the Rusty Pelican is new. And there isn't a tiki in sight.The menu has been overhauled and now features trendy items like the ahi tuna...
  • Short Order: Chef Interviews
    There's a lot of chatter surrounding the Rusty Pelican, the Key Biscayne landmark that finally reopens today after a multimillion-dollar restoration, and its salty chef, Michael...
  • Short Order: Restaurant News
    Drumroll, please! The new chef at the recently updated Rusty Pelican will be ... Michael Gilligan!Remember him from the now closed Solea (at the W South Beach) and Atrio at the Conrad? Maybe...
  • Short Order: Gastronomic Gatherings
    The Rusty Pelican, Key Biscayne's iconic spot for waterfront dining since 1972, held a closing party to celebrate both its imminent renovation and the country's birthday...
  • Calendar: Highlights
    If you and your honey ever spent an evening whispering sweet nothings over a brace of stone crab claws while taking in the Miami skyline across a shimmering Biscayne Bay from your table at...
  • Calendar: Highlights
    Isn’t embracing things of the past the new thing? In Key Biscayne, the Rusty Pelican is rewinding to 1972 – the year it opened – with a “Summer of 1972” menu....
  • Short Order: News
    Miami landmark restaurant, the Rusty Pelican is shutting down July 5 to begin a $6 million renovation project. John Tallichet, CEO of the corporation that owns the Pelican as well as...
  • Dining: Columns
    We're always looking for the ideal restaurants to take our loved ones -- naturally we want them to be impressed, feel cherished, and compliment our good taste. But what if we have to take...

Best of Award Recipient

Loading...