Benny's Seafood - Closed

2500 SW 107th Ave.
Miami, FL 33165
Benny's Seafood +

Natalia Molina


  • Sun, Tue-Thu 12pm-9pm, Fri-Sat 12pm-10pm
  • $$
  • Catering, Kid Friendly, Private Party, Takeout
  • Dinner, Lunch
  • Free Parking, Parking Lot Available
  • Reservations Accepted
Although Benny's bills itself as a seafood establishment, land and sea are equally represented on the menu. Besides, this pleasant storefront luncheonette is really known for authentic Puerto Rican cuisine. Appetizers include fried blood sausage, and green banana ceviche stocked with chicken gizzards. More gringo-friendly starters feature a variety of meat, poultry, and seafood fillings fried in empanada-dough (empanadilla) or yuca-dough (alcapurria), or tucked within a masa of yautí­a and green plantains steamed tamale-style in banana leaf (pastel). Everyone at Benny's seems to order the mofongo. You can have the fried-plantain specialty straight up or choose from an entire page of meat, poultry, and shellfish toppings. Most popular is the one piled with thick chunks of terrifically juicy fried pork. Lobster, shrimp, and snapper come breaded and fried, or sautéed in garlic and butter, or awash in a pimiento-sweetened, slightly spicy, tomato-creole sauce. Seafood dinners, with choice of two sides, range in price from $17.95 to $22.95 (Benny's is a bargain). Try chilled maví, a strange iced brew made from tree bark, or the Puerto Rican rendition of eggnog (coquito). Mostly, though, try Benny's for distinctive island cuisine from someplace other than Cuba.

Related Stories (2)

  • Dreaming in Puerto Rican
    11 years ago by Lee Klein

    I had figured my wife would be thrilled at the prospect of dining at Benny's Seafood Restaurant. After all, a reliable source recommended it to me as a "real Puerto Rican joint," and my wife is a real Puerto Rican gal. As it turned ...

  • Busman's Holiday
    18 years ago by Jen Karetnick

    'Tis the season to start dreading the holidays. Commercial warfare is on, tinsel and tacky lights are up, and hollow good cheer abounds, soon to be followed by the inevitable extra pounds. But those aren't the reasons I'm miserable....


View All

More Puerto Rican Restaurants in Miami


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >