Hero and Villain
Miguel Piñero was poet, playwright, and actor -- and thief, liar, and junkie. If everyone has within them a mix of the beautiful and the ugly, few of us have either to the extremes Piñero did. He was in Sing Sing by his early twenties, the iconic leader of New York's Puerto Rican artistic movement by age 30 and a dead junkie by 40. Yet the causes for Piñero's life trajectory remain largely unanswerable. Leon Ichaso's new biopic, Piñero (with Benjamin Bratt in the title role), gives us a lot of data and background but doesn't really try to explain so much as it merely presents. While on some level this reluctance to analyze may make the film unsatisfying for some, it is a wise move. As Mr. Thompson says at the end of Citizen Kane, you can't boil a man's life down to a single word, nor to a clear linear "explanation." To attempt such perspective is to trespass on God's turf.
What Ichaso does do is take us on a dizzying, constantly moving ride through an exciting decade in the blossoming of Nuyorican culture with its most flamboyant figure as our focus. He shows us enough of the scene and enough of the man to give us a sense of the what and the who, if not the why. Ichaso chooses as his starting point the pivotal moment in Piñero's ascent: the successful opening of Joseph Papp's New York production of Piñero's brutal drama Short Eyes, originally written and staged in prison. A TV interviewer asks him fatuous questions about his criminal background, from which Ichaso begins to flash both back and forward to show us scenes from our hero's childhood and his pathetic decline in the late Eighties.
We see his strong mother (Rita Moreno, in a small but intensely powerful role) booting his good-for-nothing dad out of the house. She tries to raise the family on her own, but still young Mikey (as he is most frequently called in the film) starts making a little extra cash by picking up older men; later he becomes a thief and ends up in Sing Sing. In a perverse way, the experience liberates him: He discovers his literary voice, not just through his plays but through writing and performing rhythmic poems that seem like a precursor of rap. (To be fair, Vachel Lindsay was doing something very similar 60 years earlier; it just didn't catch on.)
After the success of Short Eyes (which also gets turned into a feature film), Piñero finds himself in demand as a character actor, showing up on Kojak and Miami Vice and in Hollywood movies such as Fort Apache, The Bronx, Jim McBride's Breathless, and even the wretched Chevy Chase vehicle Deal of the Century. He also cofounds the Nuyorican Poets Cafe with his buddy Miguel Algarin (Giancarlo Esposito), himself a literature professor and poet. As the most famous denizen of the scene, Piñero attracts plenty of romantic admirers of both genders.
But it also begins to grow clear that he is some sort of incorrigible fuckup. Despite the Hollywood money, he still likes the high of stealing. Despite the doors opened by Short Eyes, he manages to burn patrons like Papp (played by Mandy Patinkin). Perhaps it's some long-standing pathology; perhaps it's sheer self-destructiveness. It may be that the pressure of being a "hero" is too much to deal with, or that he's afraid he'll lose his inspiration by straying too far from the street culture and underworld life that fueled his first successes.
In any case it's only a few years from his busiest, most lucrative period of acting to his sad end: homeless, living in a van, hocking his watch for smack, dying of cirrhosis. At least that's the way the film presents it; most sources say he died of AIDS. It's impossible to know why the filmmakers avoid the subject (there is a brief mention of Algarin's being HIV-positive), but in general the area the film seems most uncomfortable about is Piñero's sex life.
Ichaso -- director of less-inspired works such as Crossover Dreams and Bitter Sugar -- uses a mix-and-match patchwork of black-and-white and color shots, with lots of deliberately grainy 16mm footage and digital video tossed into the mix. Unlike, say, Christopher Nolan in Memento or Oliver Stone in JFK, he doesn't use the different looks in a rigorous scheme that signals changes of perspective or chronology. Rather, he just simulates a sense of raw documentary reality to bring us closer to New York's grit and energy.
The project originally was developed for John Leguizamo, who had to bow out late in the game because of other commitments. Leguizamo seemed like the perfect choice, and the selection of slick, pretty-boy Bratt sounded like a catastrophic change. The surprise is that Bratt (best known from TV's Law & Order and from mediocre performances in less-than-mediocre films such as The Next Best Thing and Miss Congeniality) totally redeems himself here and then some. His transformation into a stoned-out, wasted mess is completely convincing; it's the kind of flashy change-of-pace performance that has Oscar nomination written all over it, and deservedly so.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.