To put it mildly, it is uncomfortable and embarrassing to have one's cynical ass whipped by a huge hulking Hallmark card, and this is exactly the sensation one takes away from Mimi Leder's Pay It Forward. Not that the near-total emotional submission isn't preceded by a knock-down drag-out battle for one's vulgar pride; this story of making the world a better place is brimming with the milk of human kindness, and one's instincts scream to swim! thrash! struggle!, to do anything but drown in its creamy trough of prefab faith, smothering between Leder's massive paps of hope and charity. For better more than worse, however, the director and her capable cast and crew have assembled a very persuasive dunking machine, and it's not unlikely that audiences -- especially those beleaguered by the corrosion, violence, and ennui of everyday Middle America -- will gladly take the plunge.
Besides, by the time we reach the film's romantic ground zero, when a reluctant Kevin Spacey finally pulls out his Peacemaker to give Helen Hunt a little Deep Impact, Leder has reined us in with her blitzkrieg of benevolence. Resistance is futile.
But that's leaping ahead a bit. Set in the viper's nest of Vegas, where strip bars flash with unlikely production value (not to mention glitzy choreography), and cuddly homeless folks munch Dumpster yummies like friendly apes, Pay It Forward introduces us to Eugene Simonet (Spacey), a social-studies teacher who kicks off the school year by greeting his class of world-weary seventh-graders with an unusual challenge. Yes, there is a world out there, he announces, and even if you don't want to meet it, it's still going to hit you right in the face. Indeed something has hit Eugene right in the face, eliciting an initial gasp from his punk munchkins, as his neck and much of his lower jaw are covered in rubber cement designed to look like scar tissue. His challenge, complete with extra credit, is simple: Go do something that changes the world for the better. Owing to some deep, inexplicable spiritual longing (perhaps, who knows, having to do with seeing dead people?), eleven-year-old Trevor McKinney (Haley Joel Osment) overrides his initial skepticism and decides to embrace the project. Naturally he immediately invites a homeless junkie named Jerry (James Caviezel) home for some peanut butter crunch and a flop.
Pay It Forward
Based on the novel by Catherine Ryan Hyde
This creates a stir in the McKinney home, however, as Trevor's alcoholic single mother, Arlene (Hunt), works two jobs (by day a casino change girl, by night a strip-club waitress), and has no time for peculiar surprises, only dependable clandestine dates with her vodka bottle, which she keeps hidden in the washing machine. Trevor is unable to conceal his derelict charge for long, and, despite his timid presence (emphasized by a T-shirt with a deer on it), pop goes Caviezel. Arlene, enraged by what she perceives as Eugene's indirect meddling in her unhappy tract house, lets her rigid nipples lead her to the lair of the exceedingly eloquent but emotionally shielded teacher. An obvious match made in Heaven, (she's brash, he's defensive, they're both grotesque), the unlikely lovers get off on a terribly wrong foot, with Eugene praising Trevor's exegesis and Arlene feeling subjugated by the teacher's superior vocabulary. Enraged at Eugene's seeming smugness, she attacks his pet project, even when he attempts to defer responsibility for his students' actions, explaining, Every now and then they clean up a little graffiti before they lose interest.
A framing device and parallel story illustrate that Trevor's take on the assignment -- the cheesy pay-it-forward paradigm of the movie's promotional campaign (basically a plea for random acts of kind malarkey, in triplicate) -- has lost no one's interest and even gained momentum across the nation. While Trevor's classmates initiate some truly inventive schemes (one clever boy proudly establishes a Website to cajole all the children in China to jump up and down at the same time, thereby throwing the Earth off its axis), our boy-hero's plan for happy favors grows a life of its own. Cultivated by a wide spectrum of characters, ranging from token black convict Sidney (David Ramsey) to a sharp-witted white lawyer called Thorsen (Gary Wentz, the director's husband), the concept of paying it forward spreads. Connecting these dots is Chris Chandler (Jay Mohr), a crass fast-talking Los Angeles reporter (You've gone dotty! You're wearing crystal! You're keeping a few too many cats at home!) who ardently pursues the steadily growing phenomenon with his eye on the Pulitzer. When, in the movie's disjointed opening sequence, Chandler's Mustang is destroyed at a crime scene, the lawyer immediately bestows to him, with no strings attached, the keys to his pristine new Jaguar (perhaps a metaphor for Mohr's rising fees since Jerry Maguire). As the film's knowing testament to its own cuteness, Chandler initially refuses the gift, asking if it's merely an incentive for him to kill Thorsen's wife. No, replies Wentz, deadpan. Tempting ... but no.
This sort of self-reflexive wink-wink would be utterly intolerable if it didn't fit so well into the project's disarming down-with-it atmosphere. This is, after all, a world in which mothers allow their young sons to apply their deodorant, in which the nation is casually dismissed as a shithole, in which bad kids (who sneak thuddingly foreshadowed knives past their school's post-Columbine metal detectors) wear their requisite Bugle Boy fashions with pride. Based on the previously unpublished novel by Catherine Ryan Hyde, the screenplay by Leslie Dixon (Mrs. Doubtfire, Outrageous Fortune) offers a symbolic cross-section of contemporary Americana that grows more plausible as the movie simultaneously alarms and soothes our paranoid brain cells. For instance, convinced that his altruistic (yet ironically selfish) attempt to unite his teacher and his mother has failed, little Trevor decides to run away. With an understanding only another fatherless boy could muster, Eugene takes Arlene straight to the bus station, where he not only locates the child, but -- with a shocking display of vehemence bordering on exorcism -- savagely defends him from a child molester. The movie's sappy spoon-feeding grows tedious at times, but the show of warts is commendable and provides nearly ample balance.
It's a little bit sickening to be sounding the Oscar trumpet so far in advance, but the performances -- purposefully clunky, junky, and funky -- are by far this production's strongest suit. As if it weren't enough to receive fine supporting work from Jon Bon Jovi in a wife-beater shirt as Trevor's deranged father, and Angie Dickinson as an absentee alcoholic grandmother (looking for all the world like some extra out of Ironweed), the other adults arrive far above expectations. Caviezel instills his artless dodger with hangdog hope, and, for most of the story, Mohr's scoop-seeker is, fittingly, probing yet unpleasant, like some inaccurate rectal thermometer. Topping the bill, Hunt is willing to spend half the movie looking like a train wreck, and it's to her credit that she actually manages to hypnotize us into buying her as a working-class bimbo, not just expensive A-list meat dressed up as a fake prole. Her scenes with Spacey (who delivers his most vulnerable and expressive performance to date) provide plenty of emotional pyrotechnics, a welcome adjustment from the whirling cameras and effects of Leder's first two outings. When Eugene explains to Arlene, from experience, that all a father needs to do to destroy a child is simply not love him, the resonance haunts the theater.
Now, with regard to the kid. Yes, as his work in The Sixth Sense (give or take a couple of straight-to-video animated Disney projects) attests, Osment is a superb young actor, capable of holding his own in extreme closeup. The problem here is that this character doesn't allow him to stretch very far from the role that made him famous. Adoring pro-wrestling and asking smart questions of his elders (My idea -- do you think it's good, or were you just being teachery?), he's a perfect preadolescent, but the script doesn't give him adequate room to breathe. Besides, despite the ethereal new-agey strokes Dixon uses to paint him, he's just way to young to be waxing messianic.
Pay It Forward will be prompting a lot of talk this season, and possibly even some action, but there's nothing particularly new or intriguing about its elements. Goodness knows we've seen enough irritable professors fighting to educate reactionary youths (couldn't Eminem just hand out library cards?), and bum dads are a dime a thousand. By the end, when Leder has gained our undivided attention, it's a shame she decides to descend into pabulum -- a candlelight vigil by way of a Coke commercial. (Jane Siberry's Calling All Angels wafts sweetly throughout, but Courtney Love's Violet would have said plenty more.) All in all it's good to know that this gargantuan inspirational pamphlet isn't foolproof (if it were, Warner Bros. would be obliged to pay forward their copious returns). To escape the reprogramming, ask yourself this question: If someone gives you a ration of shit, should you also pay that forward?
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.