This week in theater: Two quarreling Jews and a deadly showerhead
By David Brandes and Joseph Telushkin. Based on a story by Chaim Grade. Directed by Joseph Adler. Through May 23, Gable Stage, 3000 Anastasia Ave., Coral Gables; 305-445-1119; gablestage.com.
The Quarrel follows Rabbi Hersh Rasseyner (Avi Hoffman) and journalist Chaim Kovler (Chaz Mena) through a day in a Montreal park. They are old friends, long estranged, each of whom thought the other dead. It is 1948, and they have only narrowly survived Hitler's Europe. After their happy embraces, the men take up their old arguments: Does God exist? And if He does, is He good? These arguments, so often facile games of intellectual one-gunmanship, are given gravitas by the men's shared history and by the necessary uses to which they have put their respective cosmologies — to keep the past in the past, and to keep it live-withable. What results from their fight, and from Mena and Hoffman's soulful and naturalistic acting, is a play that is slow but elegiac and lovely.
Miami local theater
Raised in Captivity
By Nicky Silver. Directed by Ricky J. Martinez. Through May 16. New Theatre, 4120 Laguna St., Coral Gables; 305-443-5909 ; new-theatre.com.
You can learn a lot at New Theatre this month. For example, actress Barbara Sloan, for so long typecast as a vengeful cougar, makes a fantastic screwball, or John Manzelli and Katherine Amadeo really should get together more. They have a magnificent and unfakeable chemistry in Raised in Captivity, a play that is both absurd and profound. It figures life as a series of breakups and vanishing acts, which are sad and, because they catch the players so unaware, blackly comic. Manzelli and Amadeo are siblings who cannot understand one another no matter how hard they try; Sloan plays their mother, who was recently killed by a flying showerhead, and Manzelli's therapist, who is so filled with self-loathing that she plucks out her eyes as an act of penance. (She seems to feel a lot better afterward.) Clint Hooper ties it all together as Amadeo's husband: a fellow who learns to follow his bliss and tells everyone else to fuck off.
By Lisa Loomer. Directed by Clive Cholerton. Through May 16. Caldwell Theatre, 7901 N. Federal Hwy., Boca Raton; 561-241-7432; caldwelltheatre.com.
Distracted is a meditation on medication, a schizo romp through a schizo world that mirrors our own a little too perfectly. Laura Turnbull plays a character called simply "Mom," the mother of a kid who can't focus. But who can? Dad (Stephen G. Anthony) is a ball of anxiety, their doctors are a mess of contradictions, and their neighbors are all getting divorces or doping their children. The play pictures suburban families in search of a moment of peace, which eludes them like Gatsby's green light — slipping further from reach the harder they strain. Lisa Loomer structures her play like a multitasker's workday: Each digression opens into more digressions; each plot line sprouts a dozen more, like Windows multiplying out of control. Eventually, one suspects, the human computers running the show will freeze.
Get the ICYMI: Today's Top Stories Newsletter Our daily newsletter delivers quick clicks to keep you in the know
Catch up on the day's news and stay informed with our daily digest of the most popular news, music, food and arts stories in Miami, delivered to your inbox Monday through Friday.