Florida's Guardians Often Exploit the Vulnerable Residents They're Supposed to Protect

Florida's Guardians Often Exploit the Vulnerable Residents They're Supposed to Protect
Illustration by Carlo Giambarresi

Lacy Waters lay on a hospital gurney, her head a hornet's nest of pain and confusion. Between the brain parasites and the drugs designed to kill them, she could hardly think — let alone answer questions. Yet that was exactly what the strangers at her bedside now demanded. As the 45-year-old Nicaraguan maid with a grade-school education desperately tried to recall the names of American presidents, the three men made careful notes on their clipboards.

A "guardian" was given control over every aspect of Lacy's life, from her medical treatment to whether she could marry the man she loved.

These men weren't her doctors, however. Instead, they had been sent by a Miami-Dade judge at the behest of Royal Caribbean — the very company Lacy blamed for her sickness.

Three years earlier, in 2005, Lacy had left Central America to work on a cruise ship. The job was supposed to be a ticket to a better life for her and her ten children. Instead, it had nearly killed her. Tapeworms — contracted from tainted pork served aboard the ship, she says — had infested her brain. Lacy was now fighting for her life. Little did she know that her visitors had just taken it from her with the stroke of a pen.

Illustration by Pat Kinsella
Illustration by Pat Kinsella

Lacy doesn't remember her visitors, but she has been suffering from their decision ever since. Based upon their 15-minute evaluation, the judge declared Lacy a ward of the state. She was instantly stripped of her most basic rights. A woman Lacy had never met was appointed her "guardian" and given control over every aspect of her life, from her medical treatment to whether she could marry the man she loved. Most important: The guardian was also in charge of her assets and finances, including Lacy's ongoing lawsuit against Royal Caribbean.

It would be five years before Lacy would win back her rights. By then, the ordeal cost her more than just her freedom. She would also lose more than $250,000.

"All I could do was cry. I was powerless," Lacy says. "Thank God I got out of it."

Despite her travails, Lacy was actually lucky. Few of the roughly 50,000 Floridians inside the state's guardianship system ever escape. And for some, losing their rights is just the beginning. In cases of abuse, they are isolated from families, overmedicated, and physically neglected while guardians bleed their accounts.

Ostensibly set up to protect the state's most vulnerable citizens, Florida's guardianship system has ­itself become dangerous. Miami-Dade's might be the most dangerous of all.

A five-month New Times investigation, which entailed reviewing thousands of pages of guardian files, has found the following:

• Miami-Dade has more than 7,000 guardianship cases — more than any other county in the state — yet has arguably the least oversight and no dedicated watchdog.

• By contrast, Palm Beach County has uncovered more than $3 million in guardianship fraud since starting its watchdog program in 2011 despite handling less than half as many cases as Miami, while Broward's watchdog has caught a dozen guardians engaging in fraud worth more than $4 million.

• There were regular failures to file basic information. Guardians were often years late in filing financial forms, and until this month, Miami-Dade lacked any electronic system to track the programs.

• Guardians have given thousands in donations to the election campaigns of the same judges who appoint them to cases and award them their fees.

As America ages and baby boomers retire, elder abuse is quickly becoming a national epidemic. Florida, the state with the oldest average population, is its epicenter. Millions of dollars are lost every year to an out-of-control system, but the cost is more than financial. For wards such as Lacy Waters, their lives are at stake. And for their family members, bad guardianships can drive them to despair and even prison.

After years of inaction, state legislators are finally addressing the issue. Two bills cracking down on guardianship abuse were recently passed in Tallahassee. But some observers warn that tougher measures are needed to solve the fundamental problems.

"There are professional guardians out there who are robbing estates blind," says Naples Rep. Kathleen Passidomo, the Republican sponsor of two successful reform bills. "Some guardians do a great job and you'd trust them with your life. But then there are some who are horrendous."


Guardianship cases can become incredibly complicated, but the basic idea is simple: Those who are too old or infirm to take care of themselves and their assets need protection. So courts appoint a "guardian," often a family member but sometimes a professional, paid either by the public or from the ward's estate.

The practice dates back to ancient Greece — where Sophocles once had to prove to a court he wasn't senile to keep his son away from his property — and has found limited use in America as far back as colonial times.

By the 1970s, though, high-profile ­horror stories exposed the Catch-22 at the heart of guardianships. Guardians are appointed to protect the incapacitated and their estates, so guardians have to be given wide leeway with those assets. That leeway is a natural gateway to abuse. All it takes is a dishonest operator to run wild.

A seminal 1972 study by George J. Alexander and Travis H.D. Lewin showed that guardianships often benefited only one party: the guardians. The two law professors recommended cutting back on their powers.

1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
All
 
Next Page »
 
My Voice Nation Help
14 comments
frankd4
frankd4 topcommenter

..........................TEN KIDS ? that beats the OCTO-mom - no ?

Faith Humeston
Faith Humeston

Very sad that these people get away with this....

Dave Denis
Dave Denis

Basically you can't trust anyone from the second you're born 'till the day you die............. Have a nice day everyone ! ;p

Frank Castle
Frank Castle

this problem is a reality and needs awareness in america but what do i do if there is elder abuse but the elder lets it happen due to the fact that the abuser is his daughter and im watching all of this on the sideline...fml

barnyard2217
barnyard2217

The thinking of these low life ghetto hood rats black, white, hispanic is that the more kids they have, the more money they can pool with their friends & cousins to buy that 52" flat screen HDTV. That's how stupid these monkeys are. What they need to realize is that they are continuing a cycle of abject poverty & crime for these children who will grow up doing the same stupid shit these hood rats are doing. Sterilization should be mandatory & or welfare benefits cut when a woman has more than two kids without obviously having used protection. I'm tired of paying for these fuc vermin.

dvaldez008
dvaldez008

This story is not about one person having 10 kids, it is about the legalization of kidnapping, abuse, ngeglect and exploitation under the laws created to protect the elderly and disabled.  People need to pay attention to stories such as this.  Judicial abuse and Guardianship abuse is occurring in every state in the USA.  This is about our future, and the destruction of American families watching their disabled and elderly loved ones being used for profits generated in Probate Courts.  The business industry of Guardianships begins in the probate courts.  It is a money making racket off of the most vulnerable citizens in our society.  One day this will happen to you or someone you love.  There is no getting out, Guardianship becomes a stranglehold on a person's life, and leaves the families devastated.  

francesvs
francesvs

its hard to believe someone would have ten kidss especially without a husband- sickening !

frankd4
frankd4 topcommenter

..................actually the "hood rats" are necessary to grease the judicial industrial complex including jails and juvenile facilities and pay judges retirement plans and LEOs overtime and health insurance all the way through to predatory towing operators hooking up unsuspecting defendants who can't pay to park at the downtown courthouse

just like the agri-giants like fertilizer manufacturers and farmers and food retailers ALL depend on SNAP (who else would a wisconsin farmer sell his all that cheeze to if the federal government didn't buy it for those "hood rats" ?)

benefits go "in the name of who ate the free government cheeze and who needs to be locked up and fed and clothed and housed BUT someone else is "profiting" - the farmer, the judge, the LEOs, Wal-Mart, towing operators, retail food stores and bodegas, and wall street

we need those monkeys and hope "breeders" keep popping-out more and more "hood rats"

mtfrieder
mtfrieder

@dvaldez008 HI, I READ YOUR COMMENT, WELL IT IS HAPPENING TO ME AS WE SPEAK. IF YOU CAN HELP ME IN ANY WAY, THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I HAVE ALL MY INFO ON A PDF FILE, AND I CAN EMAIL IT TO YOU IF YOU WANT. MY NAME IS MITCHELL FRIEDER. MY EMAIL I WILL SPELL OUT IN FULL BECAUSE THEY MIGHT BLOCK IT IF I TYPE IT ON HERE USING THE "AT SIGN". ITS MTFRIEDER AT AOL DOT COM. I HOPE TO HEAR FROM YOU. THANKS, MITCH

ssugarmd
ssugarmd

Yes, but it is so true and tragic.

 
Miami Concert Tickets
Loading...