New Times' "Pain and Gain": Murder, Drugs, and a Major Motion Picture

Read Pete Collins's three-part series "Pain and Gain."

A pudgy guy with curly hair exits a store on slummy NE 79th Street. In a van, two buff gym rats prepare to kidnap him. The bald, muscular stud in the passenger seat jumps into the back.

Then they stop what they're doing.

Then they start again.

Pete Collins on the set with extras: Livin' la vida. Read his three-part series "Pain and Gain."
Chuck Strouse
Pete Collins on the set with extras: Livin' la vida. Read his three-part series "Pain and Gain."

And again.

"Come on, guys. This is boring shit," shouts movie director Michael Bay, of Transformers fame. Wearing a Gulfstream airlines baseball hat, white pants, and a blue jacket, he leaps onto a moving camera that's filming the scene. "Dolly faster. Dolly faster."

The gym rats are actors Dwayne "the Rock" Johnson and Mark Wahlberg. The pudgy guy is Tony Shalhoub, who played Monk in the well-known TV series. Also appearing in the $25 million movie shooting this spring in Miami are stars Ed Harris and Anthony Mackie.

Pain and Gain is the latest evidence of a Tallahassee-signed, Hollywood-sealed, Michael Bay/Tom Cruise-delivered film renaissance in South Florida. Magic City, a Starz TV series about the mob in Miami, debuted April 6. In June, Rock of Ages, an $80 million musical comedy starring Cruise that was shot here, will open in theaters. Then there's Burn Notice and myriad reality shows. Thanks to increased state subsidies, Miami has recently entered the top three moviemaking locales outside California, along with Chicago and New Orleans. In Miami-Dade County, production is up 70 percent since 2010, to about $275 million a year.

See also: Pain & Gain, From New Times Story to Michael Bay Film

Pain and Gain is based on a three-part Miami New Times series penned by onetime staff writer Pete Collins and published during Christmas 1999. It's an astounding tale of kidnapping, murder, drugs, and comical ineptitude that Bay — who owns a home here and is perhaps the most successful action film director ever — fell in love with years ago. He blackmailed the studio to make it.

"Michael worked out a deal with Paramount that he would do this before he did another Transformers film," says Ian Bryce, one of Pain and Gain's two producers. "It's different in terms of story and pace than anything he's done before, but he has been attached to it for years."

I interviewed Bryce in a big-windowed building at NE 79th Street and Biscayne Boulevard that has been transformed into the Sun Gym, a Miami Lakes place that was the center of action in Collins's series. Bikini babes and Lycra-clad weightlifters with bowling-ball muscles lolled about that day. Bay was shooting a scene at a pool just outside. A catered spread of pomegranate and kiwi juices, organic bunny snacks, espresso, and bubblegum awaited the actors.

It was scant blocks from where Collins grew up in El Portal. He graduated from North Miami Senior High and then worked for the Miami News until it closed December 31, 1988. He's a 57-year-old free spirit who likes to tell the story of being handcuffed by cops on Biscayne Boulevard while playing drunken naked golf ("When I would hit a ball, I would remove an article of clothing.") or when he was fired by my predecessor, Miami New Times editor Jim Mullin ("I urinated on his car. He didn't appreciate that.").

After leaving this newspaper in 1990, he entered a master's degree program and was soon looking for a thesis topic. One morning at a Miami Shores park on NE 96th Street, he discovered the tale that would become his series Pain and Gain. A neighbor and private investigator named Ed Du Bois was washing his van. "I was taking a jog around the field, and Du Bois called me over and said, 'Pete, if you want to stop running, I have a story for you.'"

Du Bois, it turns out, was hired by an Argentine-born businessman named Marc Schiller, who had been kidnapped and tortured for a month. His attackers were a group of bodybuilders from Sun Gym. Employing a Taser, a lighter, and a loaded pistol, they had forced him to sign over bank accounts and even his home. They had also kidnapped, killed, and dismembered Golden Beach couple Frank Griga and Krisztina Furton after robbing them. The bodies — minus heads and hands — were buried in 50-gallon drums in the Everglades.

And, oh yeah, the criminals were a bunch of screwups. Kidnap vehicles wouldn't start, chain saws failed to cut up bodies, and too much horse tranquilizer was used on one victim. Two gang members would end up on death row. Their tale was Miami's Pulp Fiction.

Local Judge Alex Ferrer, a handsome former cop who would later star in a television show called Judge Alex, heard the case. He grew attached to Collins, who attended the proceedings every day. "That was the longest criminal prosecution in Dade County history," Ferrer says. "A brutal and gruesome case."

Darcy Shepard was a juror. "It had all the makings of a movie from the first day of testimony," she says, “the kind of thing you could never imagine in real life."

After sitting through the trial, Collins wrote a book's worth of material but couldn't sell it. Then he showed up in the New Times offices and delivered the manuscript to his former boss, Mullin. I was managing editor at the time and one of those who devoured the manuscript and recommended publishing it. Editor Dinah McNichols did much work on the piece. I did a final read.

Next Page »
My Voice Nation Help
Marc S.
Marc S.

Too bad they did not consult me, It would have been a better movie. After all I was the one that gave Pete most of the story.

Ed DuBois Fan
Ed DuBois Fan

Congratulations to Pete Collins (& Ed DuBois!)

cole younger
cole younger

This is great for Miami.....I think ????


Shalhoub is not pudgy. Collins is what you would call pudgy. But fascinating story.

Tom Stedham
Tom Stedham

Speaking as one of the "extras" who didn't show back up...

I was booked and confirmed for 4 days work. I turned down bookings on the two tv shows filmed here, to take this gig. It's with Wahlberg; who wouldn't, right?

After one long (loooong) day poolside baking in the sun, I leave at 8:30 pm. I'm confirmed with casting to return tomorrow, 7 am. On the train, 20 minutes later, I get a cancellation. "Michael has changed some things around. We don't need you."

No matter the original (confirmed) booking. No matter that casting had just confirmed me for the next day. I call my "agent". "Oh well. It happens," I'm told.

No concern for missed work; no concern for cancelling a confirmed booking. Certainly no compensation for cancelling 3 days of booked work. Just... "oh well."

THAT is how extras are often treated, and it is why some extras come and go. Because we are sometimes treated as just that: "EXTRAS"...

Sadly, this is life at the bottom of the acting food chain.

Miami Concert Tickets