Bad Aim

Alex Bailey

Finally a movie about Stalingrad that leaves out all the complicated messy bits

Details

Based on the book Enemy at the Gates by William Craig. Opening at selected theaters.

Related Content

• 2012 Village Voice Film Poll Results
  January 3, 2013
• "Pain & Gain" Writer Pete Collins' 15 Minutes of Fame Have Arrived
  April 25, 2013
• The Bourne Legacy Suffers From a Sense of Damonlessness
  August 9, 2012
• Side Effects May Induce Queasy Pleasure
  February 7, 2013
• 360 Movie Review: Spread Out and Empty
  August 16, 2012

More About

• Jean-Jacques Annaud
• Ed Harris
• Nikita Khrushchev
• Communism
• World War II

But Annaud and Godard aren't content with merely recounting the face-off between two warriors. They insist on recounting the entire myth, which comes complete with a love triangle between Danilov, Vassili, and a Russian soldier named Tania (Rachel Weisz). Danilov wants to use Tania, who can read German, as a translator of intercepted communiqués, but she insists on being assigned to the front. As a Jew whose parents were murdered by the Nazis, she seeks revenge with a rifle, not a pen. Danilov wants Vassili to talk her out of fighting, but it's a moot point: Vassili and Tania are comrades-in-arms, literally (they make love amid sleeping soldiers in one touching, almost erotic scene that's less about showing and more about feeling). Danilov, upon discovering their relationship, goes nearly mad, threatening to "reveal" his heroic sniper as a traitorous coward.

The love story, not to mention plot holes large enough to swallow entire platoons, so bogs down the movie that whatever tension the Vassili-Konig confrontation creates disappears every time Weisz appears onscreen; she tears apart comrades -- and the movie. By the end we care little whether this is a true story because Annaud has rendered his tale so mushy and, worse, predictable that we feel more manipulated than moved. It's as though Annaud had so little faith in his main story that he felt the need to turn a subplot into his entire plot:World War II as the world's worst first date.