By Michael E. Miller
By Ryan Yousefi
By Kyle Munzenrieder
By Sabrina Rodriguez
By Michael E. Miller
By Carlos Suarez De Jesus
By Luther Campbell
By Kyle Munzenrieder
Twenty-one years later it appears that the will of the people doesn't amount to much. A provision in the charter amendment has allowed the city commission to grant waivers to the mandatory setback. Over the years politicians, acting at the behest of developers, routinely have ignored a principle voters thought they'd enshrined in law: Access to Miami's waterfront should be a public right, not a luxury reserved for millionaires.
The American Airlines Arena; the Hotel Inter-Continental; and the Hyatt Regency hotel, just northwest of the Brickell Avenue bridge, are a few of the developments that received waivers to the setback requirement.
Now, as the Miami River Commission and the Trust for Public Land prepare to unveil an ambitious new plan for a comprehensive Miami River greenway path to run from State Road 112 near the airport all the way to Biscayne Bay, the Miami City Commission once again has voted to approve a waiver to the waterfront setback law. This time the parcel of land in question is particularly significant and symbolic: It lies at the mouth of the river, precisely where the greenway is to begin.
This past December 14 an all-star cast of lawyers, architects, and consultants representing a project called One Miami came before the commission to request a waiver to the setback requirement. More than a dozen private citizens also were there, intent on persuading commissioners to deny the request.
The waterfront property slated for development is a sliver of land immediately south of the Inter-Continental Hotel and east of the Dupont Plaza building. Despite its petite size -- not quite three acres -- developers hope to erect two towers on the site. As presented to the commission, one of the buildings would be residential, soaring 49 stories into the air and offering 425 pricey condominiums. A second tower, largely dedicated to office space, would rise 34 stories. Shops and restaurants would fill its bottom floors. Additionally developers contemplated a twelve-story garage with 1800 parking spaces.
The land forms part of a nine-acre site collectively called One Miami Centre, much of which consists of parking lots just north of the Dupont Plaza building. In 1998 a consortium of Boca Raton-based developers headed by Ned Siegel and Morris Stoltz purchased the entire nine acres with the goal of transforming them into a landmark downtown development.
Developer Jorge Perez and his company The Related Group of Florida agreed to plunk down a million-dollar deposit on the waterfront portion of the property with an option to buy it -- contingent on receiving a setback waiver. Perez, whose company is the top condo developer in South Florida, hired Miami's premier architects, Arquitectonica, to design his part of the project.
The firm drafted plans for buildings that, at several points, would sit closer to the water than the required 50 feet. The design also includes a road that would cut through the proposed greenway to reach a parking garage on the site. With the inclusion of benches and other additions, the project calls for only about fourteen feet of public walkway along the water.
A highly successful developer, Jorge Perez is no stranger to Miami politics. He co-chaired, with Miami-Dade County Mayor Alex Penelas, a committee that attempted to land the 2000 Democratic Convention in Miami, and he serves as a member of the influential Hispanic businessmen's civic group Mesa Redonda. This past July he held a swanky fundraiser in support of the candidacy of Miami Mayor Joe Carollo's brother Frank, who sought a seat in the state House of Representatives. (Despite raising more money, Carollo lost to incumbent Manuel Prieguez.) Leaving nothing to chance, Perez hired Greenberg Traurig attorney Lucia Dougherty, a well-connected land-use expert, for the One Miami effort. He also employed former Miami assistant city manager Dena Bianchino to work on the project. After ten months with The Related Group, Bianchino returned to her old job at the city, albeit with a pay raise.
Tony Doris, a columnist with the Miami Daily Business Review, was the first to flag the awkwardness of this arrangement. Although Bianchino has recused herself from working on Perez's development as a city official, she does supervise the planning staff that had to decide whether to recommend approval of it. As Doris wrote in his column: "Now ask yourself how likely you'd be to speak up if you were one of her employees and you felt a need to criticize the work that she dedicated months to finessing."
City staff recommended commissioners waive the setback requirement, having concluded that the proposed development met the threshold for justifying such action: It must "provide a public benefit." Examples contained in the statute include direct public access, public walkways, and plazas. Perez's One Miami project promised all these.