The sophomore slump is a popular phenomenon in modern music. A band's debut release does well; the next album falls short of expectations as the group stumbles to re-create the magic that brought fans into its realm in the first place. Maybe this lack of inspiration is owing to a lost grasp of reality as the old, rusting tour van is traded in for an air-conditioned charter bus with a Jacuzzi. Maybe it's simply the pressure to be bigger and better from the record company, the fans, and the band members themselves. Or maybe it's because the artists traded serious songwriting for constant touring and decadent after-show parties.
Fortunately Cibo Matto has managed to squash that notion with its latest album, Stereotype A, a mindbending audio adventure that far outshines the last full-length effort from Yuka Honda, Miho Hatori, and friends. While 1996's Viva! La Woman allowed the band to hunt down its voice with a schizophrenic blend of samples, hip-hop drum loops, and strange lyrics, Stereotype A reveals a more sophisticated Cibo Matto, with all the hooks, surprises, and deft songwriting that make a great pop album.
Sure the band is still as quirky as ever, and Hatori's vocals can take awhile to get used to, but this fourteen-track collection is one of the most creative and boundary-smashing pop releases since Radiohead's O.K. Computer. Why? Honda, who produced the album herself, traded in the stock samples that were used to build Viva! La Woman in favor of live playing and the reconstructed riffing of her musician friends, including John Medeski and Billy Martin of Medeski, Martin & Wood, inventive guitarist Marc Ribot, Soul Coughing's bassist Sebastian Steinberg, and jazz trumpeter Dave Douglas (not to mention Cibo Matto's multi-instrumentalist members themselves: Hatori, Honda, Timo Ellis, and Sean Lennon). The intricate harmonies and worldly melodies are impeccable. And the advanced chords and song structures are much more interesting than the majority of what MTV's staples pound out. There's a little something for almost everyone here: deep, complex, and drugged-out production; danceable grooves; and sophisticated composition. It's music that can be listened to on many levels. This is mind pop.
So what happened since Viva! La Woman? When that album was released, many may have thought this was just a joke band. Loosely translated, Cibo Matto means "crazy food" in Italian. The group's debut was made up of songs with titles like "Beef Jerky," "White Pepper Ice Cream," and "Artichoke." As Yuka Honda explains by phone from her apartment in New York City, the recurring food motif might have been a bit too bizarre for people to deal with. After the record was released, she and Hatori fielded plenty of fluffy questions from music journalists (i.e., "What's your favorite food?"). And as articles about Cibo Matto were published, it was sometimes painted as a novelty act or at least a very gimmicky band. So this time around, Honda and Hatori took a step away from the food metaphors with hopes to be taken a little more seriously.
"When we were working on our first record, everything was happening so fast and we were just trying to keep up," Honda says. "This time we knew what it means to put out an album, that we'd have to live with it and talk about it for a long time, so we were more prepared. We knew from the previous experience that once you have one concept, everyone will ask about it. For Viva! La Woman the recurring theme was food as a metaphor. That was just one of the elements on the album, though."
When Honda and Hatori sat down to name this latest album, they blurted out whatever popped in their minds. One subject kept slipping into the brainstorming session: how so many problems in the world arise from stereotypes.
"We figured that since we would be spending a lot of time explaining ourselves to people, it might be nice to talk less about food and more about stereotypes," Honda says. "Plus, the title contains the word stereo and that was really exciting to me."
Because she produced and arranged the record with minimal help, Honda thinks this release more clearly shows the ideas in her and Hatori's minds. With a recording time line spread across nearly fourteen months, Cibo Matto was able to experiment much more than it could on the Mitchell Froom/Tchad Blake-produced Viva! La Woman. One element that is much more apparent on this release is the use of harmonies. Honda says many of her multiple-voice ideas came from her and bandmate/boyfriend Sean Lennon's mutual love of Beach Boy Brian Wilson's harmonies.
"Every day I wake up and Sean is listening to Brian Wilson big-time," she explains. "We've talked a lot about how amazing his harmonies are, how they emphasize the melody within a song, and it definitely made me want to use a lot of harmony on this record. There's one [Beach Boys] song that I absolutely love called "Til I Die" [from the 1971 album Surf's Up]. We used to listen to it and it would totally make me cry. The human voice is just an amazing instrument that can create some intense feelings."