By Michael E. Miller
By Ryan Yousefi
By Kyle Munzenrieder
By Sabrina Rodriguez
By Michael E. Miller
By Carlos Suarez De Jesus
By Luther Campbell
By Kyle Munzenrieder
Using this passionate rhetoric, Mason, along with lobbyist and fellow nudist Ramon Maury, launched a grassroots campaign that has deluged the committee with hundreds of messages and letters from outraged naturists in Florida and abroad.
The committee flinched. Slightly. Although a watered-down bill that restricted nudity in state parks passed in a close vote, the proposed measure -- which has not yet been considered by the full House or Senate -- would not affect the most popular clothing-optional beaches in South Florida, Haulover Beach and South Beach. Even so, Mason and Maury remain vigilant. "Once this bill goes to the floor, it's fair game for anyone who wants to amend it," Maury warns. "The mood of the new legislature is to take away this freedom from families and consenting adults."
If the wrangling in committee is any guide, a citizen's right to sunbathe in the altogether won't be stripped away without a fight. In the state capital, the legislative equivalent of mud-wrestling over nudity is becoming an annual tradition.
This latest bill, as proposed by State Rep. Buddy Johnson (R-Plant City), originally aimed to prohibit anyone from being "naked or in a nude state in public except in any place provided or set apart for that purpose," making that offense a first-degree misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in jail. It was amended in committee to cover only state parks. The measure seeks to remedy what advocates see as a loophole in the state's indecent-exposure statute; state and federal courts have ruled that the section of that statute dealing with "exposure of sexual organs" does not bar nudity unless accompanied by "vulgar and indecent" behavior. In 1993, for instance, a federal magistrate overturned the arrests of eight nude sunbathers at Canaveral National Seashore (U.S. v. A Naked Person Issued Notice of Violation No. P41940), prompting state and national park officials, along with the religious right, to push for new legislation to sharply limit public nudity. That set off a fusillade of lobbying in the last legislative session, with the conservative American Family Association of Florida summoning its troops and allies to do battle with a variety of nudist organizations.
The anti-nudists' main argument is this: Anyone can walk naked anywhere without getting arrested. Baloney, say nude-niks, who point out that the state's disorderly conduct statute permits such arrests. Though a Senate committee approved an anti-nudity bill, no new law resulted. "That [nudity issue] assault grabbed everyone's attention, and we had no time to attend to other issues," complains one legislative staffer rubbed raw by the politicking.
This year Criminal Justice Committee chairman Elvin Martinez (D-Tampa) said he wanted to avoid any distractions by bringing up the matter early in January. (The bill was quietly introduced by the chairman himself, in part because Johnson, its chief supporter, doesn't sit on the committee.) Richard Mason hints at a darker motivation: "The leadership engendered the bill quickly before we could know about it because they didn't want to put up with our lobbying." Indeed, the "nonclothing community" didn't learn about the bill and the committee's plans for a January 24 hearing until the second week of January -- but then they quickly swung into action.
Hell, it seems, hath no fury like a nudist scorned. Beginning on the weekend of January 13, Mason and Maury, among others, contacted members of the "Non-Group," a coalition representing about 40 Florida nudist clubs that have a combined membership of 45,000. Those leaders contacted their members and began bombarding members of the committee with letters and faxes. Dade tourist industry officials were also notified, leading some, including Don Meginley of the Ocean Drive Association, to pen blistering missives. "Does everyone in Tallahassee insist on being offensive to our European visitors to South Beach, or is everyone in Tallahassee just stupid?" Meginley wrote. "Either way, the Florida legislature should be working on getting people to come to Florida, not create bills which chase them away."
At the same time, Mason prepared 4500 copies of an inflammatory leaflet and distributed it at local beaches. "LEGISLATIVE ALERT!" it virtually screamed. "If you are reading this on Miami Beach or Haulover Beach and you are nude or top-free, you will be a criminal on October 1, 1995," referring to the date on which a new law, if passed, would take effect. The back of each leaflet listed committee members to contact. Mason also arranged to post similar information on the Internet and America On-Line.
"The lobbying was very heavy, from all over the world," confirms Lynn Cobb, staff director of the Criminal Justice Committee. "My chairman used up an entire ream of fax paper [receiving messages]." Arriving from as far away as Australia, the protests warned that foreign visitors wouldn't come to Florida and derided the bill as unnecessary and costly. "We do not want our tax dollars wasted on such a preposterous boondoggle!" wrote Bruce Frendahl, a former president of South Florida Free Beaches.